Surrey property owners lose bid to have land reclassified as farm
Landowners in Surrey have lost their bid to have their property reclassified as a developing farm, with the province's Property Appeal Assessment Board finding using the parcel for that purpose would be "untenable."
Farmland in B.C., the board points out, is "invariably" assessed at a value "well below the land's actual value" – meaning there is a financial benefit to having a property classified as a farm.
The 9.5-acre lot – which is zoned for agricultural use – was classified as residential and assessed at $2.761 million. In October of last year, Dhanda, Jasmin and Balbir Dhana applied to have it classified as a tree farm, a move that followed three similar applications in previous years.
"However, none of these initiatives ever resulted in a viable farm operation," the assessment appeal decision notes.
The application said the land was being cultivated, specifically that the owners had planted 4,000 cedar trees in 2022 and 100 fruit trees in 2021 and that the plan was to sell these trees in the coming years. In addition, the owners claimed they were using three acres of the land for hay production and had already sold hundreds.
An inspection found the land did not have an adequate irrigation source, that cedar seedlings were not planted in a way that would properly promote their growth, and that harvesting the hay would be extremely difficult given the crop was sparse and the condition of the land.
The report also noted another significant problem.
"Weed control is a known essential practice with respect to agriculture and it has not been managed appropriately," the inspection report is quoted as saying.
"The sound agricultural practice of weed control is not present. This is the case for both hay and tree cultivation."
The appeal board explained that classifying the land as a developing farm is only possible if the assessor is satisfied that a "viable" operation is underway or will be "established within certain time parameters."
In this case, the board said the evidence raised questions about whether the claimed number of trees had been planted before the owners' application was submitted – or planted at all.
In addition, the "excessive mortality" among the seedlings that were found on the property was due to factors such as "weeds, inappropriate spacing, heat, and lack of water."
To succeed, the applicants would have had to demonstrate their crops were being "farmed in accordance with sound agricultural practices'" and "properly cultivated."
The board was not convinced this was the case on this particular property.
"The appellants’ bid to have their land parcel classified as farm based on its status as a 'developing farm' is, based on the evidence before me, untenable," the decision said, upholding the assessment of the property as residential.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
A turbulent campaign nears its finale as Americans choose between Harris and Trump
A presidential campaign marked by upheaval and rancour headed for its Election Day finale on Tuesday, as Americans decided whether to send Donald Trump back to the White House or elevate Kamala Harris to the Oval Office.
Government calls $9M condo purchase an 'operational decision'
Foreign Affairs Minister Melanie Joly defends the purchase of a $9 million condo for the Consulate General of New York City at a parliamentary committee, as a necessary investment.
New homeowners find skeleton in attic 15 years after previous occupant disappeared
Homeowners in France have discovered a skeleton in the attic of an outbuilding while undertaking renovation work.
B.C.'s chief electoral officer defends election integrity after 'human errors'
British Columbia's chief electoral officer says "extremely challenging weather conditions" and a new voting system factored into human errors that saw ballots go uncounted in the provincial election — though none were large enough to change results.
Trump snaps at reporter when asked about abortion: 'Stop talking about that'
Donald Trump is refusing to say how he voted on Florida's abortion measure -- and getting testy about it.
Lamborghini driver who crashed into parked cars while trying to pass streetcar sentenced to prison
A mortgage broker who totalled his Lamborghini and left a passenger with life-altering injuries after trying to pass a Toronto streetcar at nearly three times the speed limit has been handed a two-and-a-half year prison sentence.
'I’m not proud of it': Jason Kelce apologizes after video shows him spiking a cellphone after fan used a homophobic slur
Jason Kelce issued an apology during ESPN's 'Monday Night Countdown' after a viral video captured a 'heated moment' between the retired Super Bowl champion and a fan over the weekend.
Trudeau and Harris? Poilievre and Trump? Here's who Canadians think would work best with: survey
As Americans prepare to elect their next president on Tuesday, new data from the Angus Reid Institute suggests Canadians hold differing views as to which federal party leaders would be best suited to deal with either Donald Trump or Kamala Harris.
Netanyahu fires Israeli defence minister Yoav Gallant, after months of clashes over war and politics
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has fired Defence Minister Yoav Gallant after months of clashes over domestic politics and Israel’s war efforts.