Ordering B.C. woman to reimburse ex-employer for 'time theft' sets alarming precedent, lawyer says
A small claims case in which a B.C. woman was ordered to reimburse her former employer for "time theft" after she was fired is not only rare, but has dangerous implications, says a labour lawyer.
An accountant who worked from home was required to pay $1,500 to compensate the company for 50.76 hours of time that the BC Civil Resolution Tribunal found the employer had proven was not spent on work. As evidence, in part, the company submitted video taken from tracking software on the worker's laptop.
"I was quite surprised and concerned by it," lawyer William Clements told CTV News.
"There's certain particular facts and evidence that created this result, with an adjudicator that I don't think was thinking through the implications of quantifying what she called 'time theft' and then hitting the ex-employee with it. It's very novel, and I think it's a very dangerous road to venture down."
Clements, who primarily represents workers and whose clients are mainly unions, described the case as exceptional – not because the woman was fired, but because the company claimed and was awarded compensation for the behaviour it cited as cause for her termination.
He said it's something he has never seen before and the decision left him troubled.
"The implication of saying, 'You were doing your own thing on the computer rather than what we expected and required of you means we're now going to quantify the value of the time we think you wasted while you were an employee, pay us back.' It shocked me," he said.
"It has, I think, some very dangerous implications for lots of different scenarios where people have not fulfilled the expectations of their employer."
Lawyer Eleni Kassaris, a partner at Dentons who primarily represents employers, said she was also struck by the uniqueness of the case.
"What did stand out for me was that they assess the time theft damages at all," she said, echoing Clements' sentiment that termination alone is usually the only recourse sought by employers, but not his concern that these cases may become more common.
"Proving and getting compensated as an employer because someone stole time, it's going to be a small number of cases where that's possible," she noted, saying in many cases – as in this one – the actual amount of money a company would be awarded would be quite small.
Both lawyers note that the company did not initiate the legal action in this case, but only made the time theft claim in response to the woman filing her own claim alleging wrongful dismissal.
TIME THEFT
Kassaris said that the issue of time theft predates both the increase in remote work due to the pandemic and the use of tracking software, and that it generally is considered a legitimate reason to fire someone.
But it has to be proven.
"It's hard to get around the fact that you're trying to basically rip off your employer. So, whether it's actually stealing from the cookie jar, misappropriating funds – stealing is the type of conduct that, if the employer can show that you did it, I think they're justified in terminating for cause," she told CTV News.
A "classic" example she offers is working somewhere where employees punch time cards, clocking in and out for shifts and breaks. If someone were to stay home, have someone else punch the card for them and then get paid for those hours, it would be an example of getting paid for time not worked.
However, in most cases – including work-from-home scenarios, even with tracking software installed – proving time theft is not this straightforward, particularly in the case of salaried employees, Kassaris said.
"I think you have to have the element of actual intention to steal the time," she said, which she notes is different than someone who is "slacking off" or spending time in a way the employer judges is not productive.
Also, she said measuring the precise amount of time spent on work is not so simple and that employees are generally not paid solely or exclusively in exchange for minutes or hours of tasks performed.
"The value that employees bring to work or their jobs is not usually that simply quantifiable," she said.
Clements agrees, although he is more critical of the very notion of time theft, saying people's time does not belong to their employer.
"In human terms, it's impossible and kind of a terrifying prospect that we would be tracking every minute and moment of anyone's day and trying to attach a wage or a direct economic value to that that we can then declare to have been stolen," he said.
The decision, like any from the Civil Resolution Tribunal, can be appealed. The woman at the centre of the case would likely need a lawyer to have a chance at successfully appealing the ruling given that a legitimate legal error would need to be identified and challenged.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
'A beautiful soul': Funeral held for baby boy killed in wrong-way crash on Highway 401
A funeral was held on Wednesday for a three-month-old boy who died after being involved in a wrong-way crash on Highway 401 in Whitby last week.
Police handcuff man trying to enter Drake's Toronto mansion
Toronto police say a man was taken into custody outside Drake's Bridle Path mansion Wednesday afternoon after he tried to gain access to the residence.
U.S. presidential candidate RFK Jr. had a brain worm, has recovered, campaign says
Independent U.S. presidential candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. had a parasite in his brain more than a decade ago, but has fully recovered, his campaign said, after the New York Times reported about the ailment.
Blind Sask. boy heading to international braille competition hopes to increase accessibility for visually impaired
A Saskatchewan boy who qualified for an international braille competition in Los Angeles next month hopes he can inspire change in his home province.
'A step forward': New screening criteria for sperm donors takes effect
Canadians looking to grow their families with the assistance of sperm or egg donations should soon have more options for donors as the federal health agency does away with longstanding restrictions criticized as discriminatory.
Ontario Provincial Police arrest 64 suspects in child sexual exploitation investigation
Ontario Provincial Police say 64 suspects are facing a combined 348 charges in connection with a series of child sexual exploitation investigations that spanned the province.
What is whooping cough and should Canadians be concerned as Europe declares outbreak?
There is currently a whooping cough epidemic in Europe, with 10 times as many cases compared to the previous two years. While an outbreak has not been declared nationwide in Canada, whooping cough is regularly detected in the country.
Pfizer agrees to settle more than 10K lawsuits over Zantac cancer risk: Bloomberg News
Pfizer has agreed to settle more than 10,000 lawsuits about cancer risks related to the now discontinued heartburn drug Zantac, Bloomberg News reported on Wednesday, citing people familiar with the deal.
Steve Albini, legendary producer for Nirvana, the Pixies and an alternative rock pioneer, dies at 61
Steve Albini, an alternative rock pioneer and legendary producer who shaped the musical landscape through his work with Nirvana, the Pixies, PJ Harvey and more, has died. He was 61.