Decision upholding B.C. man's eviction for unpaid rent was patently unreasonable, court rules
![B.C. 10-day eviction notice Part of a blank B.C. 10-day notice to end tenancy form is shown. (gov.bc.ca)](/content/dam/ctvnews/en/images/2024/8/16/b-c--10-day-eviction-notice-1-7003979-1723843872989.png)
A B.C. Supreme Court judge has thrown out a ruling by the province's Residential Tenancy Branch and ordered it to reconsider the question of whether a tenant should be evicted over $13,300 in unpaid rent.
The tenant in question, Andro Sanchez, acknowledged that he withheld that amount from the rent payments to his landlord Yan Hong Bao, but told the RTB and the court that he did so because of a "long-standing arrangement" in which he paid for certain expenses – such as property taxes – and withheld the amounts from his rent.
In a decision issued Wednesday, Justice Wendy A. Baker found that the RTB arbitrator who upheld the eviction had not adequately considered – or even considered at all – whether the purported withholding arrangement justified Sanchez's unpaid rent.
Why was the money withheld?
According to Baker's decision, Sanchez told the court he withheld rent payments in December 2023 and January and February 2024 as compensation for renovation work he did to create a basement suite in the home.
Bao, who lives in China, had expressed a desire to increase the amount of money he was earning from the property, Sanchez told the court. The tenant said he offered to construct a basement suite that could be rented out to generate additional revenue.
"Mr. Sanchez says that he prepared a budget and the landlord agreed that Mr. Sanchez could do the work and deduct expenses from his rent," Baker's decision reads.
The decision does not specify where in B.C. the rental property is located.
In March, Bao hired a local management company to serve Sanchez with a 10-day notice to end tenancy for unpaid rent.
Sanchez challenged the notice at the RTB, which issued its decision upholding the eviction in April.
Bao also brought a separate complaint to the RTB seeking compensation for the unpaid rent, but he withdrew this complaint when the arbitrator awarded him compensation as part of the eviction decision.
Sanchez petitioned the court for a judicial review of the case, arguing both that the RTB ruling was patently unreasonable and that its process had been procedurally unfair.
No 'rational or tenable line of analysis'
Baker's decision was the result of Sanchez's judicial review petition, and it finds in his favour on both the reasonableness and the fairness issues.
The judge noted that the RTB arbitrator's decision was "very brief," and – while it acknowledged Sanchez's argument that he had an arrangement allowing him to withhold rent to cover agreed-upon expenses – did not make a determination about whether the alleged arrangement was valid.
The "primary question" before the arbitrator, according to Baker, was whether or not the evidence supported that the parties had an agreement to allow Sanchez to deduct renovation costs from the rent.
"Having read the decision in its entirety, I cannot see any rational or tenable line of analysis which addresses this fundamental issue," the decision reads.
"The arbitrator simply repeated the fact that the tenant had not paid the rent, without addressing the underlying argument as to whether such a withholding accorded with an agreement between the parties. In the absence of any analysis addressing the fundamental issue in the dispute, I find the decision is so flawed that no amount of curial deference can justify letting it stand. It is patently unreasonable."
Baker also noted that Sanchez included an email from Bao in his response to the landlord's RTB complaint that "appears to support his position." As reproduced in the court decision, the relevant line of the email reads: "The cost of your basement is deducted from the rent."
Sanchez attempted to refer to this or other evidence during the RTB hearing, but he was unable to find what he was looking for before the hearing's one-hour time limit expired, according to Baker's decision.
The RTB arbitrator reassured him that he would have the opportunity to present his evidence at a second hearing specifically on Bao's unpaid rent complaint, but when the landlord withdrew that complaint, Sanchez lost this chance.
Baker's decision indicates that the RTB arbitrator was required to make a monetary award at the same time that Sanchez's challenge to the notice to end tenancy was denied. The judge found the arbitrator had failed to make that fact clear.
"The failure of the director to ensure that the related disputes were heard together, and to ensure that all evidence relating to the issue of unpaid rent filed in both disputes was before the arbitrator on April 15, 2024, coupled with the misleading reassurance by the arbitrator during the hearing, resulted in a hearing which was procedurally unfair to Mr. Sanchez," Baker's decision reads.
The judge ordered the RTB ruling to be set aside and remanded the case back to that body for a rehearing.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.7033216.1726021317!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
FACT CHECK: A look at the false and misleading claims made during the Trump-Harris debate
In their first and perhaps only debate, former U.S. president Donald Trump and U.S. Vice-President Kamala Harris described the state of the country in starkly different terms. As the two traded jabs, some old false and misleading claims emerged along with some new ones.
Singh not 'anxious' to launch election, says his top adviser
Jagmeet Singh's top adviser says the NDP leader is not particularly eager to trigger an election. But Anne McGrath, Singh's principal secretary, says there will be more volatility in Parliament and the odds of an early election have risen.
Quebec woman wins MAID case to die at home after legal fight with landlord
A woman who requested medical assistance in dying (MAID) won a major case in front of the Quebec rental board. She wanted to die at home, but her landlord didn't want her to.
Key takeaways from a debate that featured tense clashes and closed with a Taylor Swift endorsement
Donald Trump and Kamala Harris faced each other on the debate stage for the first — and possibly the last — time.
Liberals put up united front after fractious summer at Nanaimo retreat
Liberal MPs will have one last chance to tell their leader how they think their party can improve their political prospects before they return to Ottawa to face off against Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre in the House of Commons.
Mother of suspected Apalachee High School shooter apologizes to victims' families in open letter
The mother of the teenager suspected of killing four people during last week’s shooting at a Georgia high school has apologized to the victims' families in an open letter while insisting her son 'is not a monster.'
Some restaurants have increased their default tip options. Canadians think you should give this much
Despite what the default options on the payment terminal might read, most Canadians still want to tip around 15 per cent, according to a new survey.
Parents fight for change after 13-year-old girl dies in B.C. homeless camp
Brianna McDonald's death was caused by a suspected overdose, according to her family. And her grieving parents are urging change so other families don’t have to face what they are going though.
'EI kind of folks': Cape Breton MP criticized for comment about Atlantic Canadians
Nova Scotia Liberal MP Jaime Battiste is taking some heat for a remark about Atlantic Canadians.