B.C. mom who suffocated 8-year-old daughter appealing prison sentence
Warning: This story contains disturbing details
A B.C. woman who suffocated her eight-year-old daughter using a plastic bag is appealing her prison sentence, leaving the victim's long-suffering family frustrated and afraid.
Lisa Batstone murdered her daughter Teagan back in 2014, and her case has been winding through the courts ever since, a process the child's father said continues to reopen painful emotional wounds.
"How egregious it seems that someone who took the life of a child can have so many opportunities and avenues to try and avoid responsibility," Gabe Batstone told CTV News over the phone on Wednesday.
"It makes it pretty hard to heal."
The mother, who was found guilty of second-degree murder in 2019, has already mounted an unsuccessful appeal of her conviction. The B.C. Prosecution Service confirmed the case is scheduled to return to court again early next month so she can seek a lighter sentence.
Lisa Batstone is currently serving life in prison with no possibility of parole for 15 years. Her ex-husband said he would fear for his family’s safety if the killer's lawyer were to successfully petition for the minimum of 10 years without parole.
"When I think about the seven decades of Teagan's life that she took away, it just seems unfathomable to me that she could be walking free anytime, let alone, you know, just a few years from now," he said.
"I think that's a scary thing. And it presents a risk to our family and to others."
The court heard the Batstones divorced in 2010, when Teagan was two, and that the mother continued to feel "great resentment" toward her ex-husband. After the murder, she left notes around her home with messages that included "you win."
The defence said Lisa Batstone had been dealing with a number of issues, including financial difficulties and mental illness. Her notice of appeal argues the trial judge failed to "treat Ms. Batstone's mental illness as a significant mitigating factor" during sentencing.
The hearing for her appeal is scheduled for May 10.
With files from CTV News Vancouver's Maria Weisgarber
Shopping Trends
The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at CTV News. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop. Read about us.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
G2 driver stopped going more than 100 km/h over the speed limit on Hwy. 401 in eastern Ontario
A 17-year-old driver is facing charges after being caught speeding and driving dangerously on Highway 401 in eastern Ontario Friday evening, according to the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP).
Calgary Skyview MP George Chahal joins growing chorus of Liberals calling for Trudeau to step down
Calgary Liberal MP George Chahal has publicly released letters he sent to the Liberal caucus and president of the Liberal Party of Canada, calling on them to begin the process of moving on from Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.
How some men are trying to fight online misogyny amid 'your body, my choice' rhetoric
A young man with a buzz cut leans on a pristine countertop in a stark white kitchen and looks directly into the camera as he delivers what he presents as the secret to dating success for straight men.
New Canadians, non-traditional demographics boost minor hockey uptake in B.C.
Participation in hockey in British Columbia was struggling in 2021 — the pandemic had dealt a heavy blow to player registrations, and numbers had already been flagging before COVID-19 arrived.
Trudeau, Carney push back over Trump's ongoing 51st state comments
Two senior members of the federal cabinet were in Florida Friday pushing Canada's new $1.3 billion border plan with members of Donald Trump's transition team, a day after Prime Minister Justin Trudeau himself appeared to finally push back at the president-elect over his social media posts about turning Canada into the 51st state.
Physical therapy is 'the best-kept secret in health care'
If you think physical therapy is only about rehabilitation after surgery or recovering from an accident, think again. For the vast majority, seeing a physical therapist should be about prevention, routine assessment and staying well.
Sportscaster Greg Gumbel dies from cancer at age 78
Greg Gumbel, a longtime CBS sportscaster who broke barriers during his career calling some of the biggest sporting events, has died from cancer, according to a statement from his family released by the network on Friday. He was 78.
The husband-wife legal team working on two of today’s biggest criminal cases
The rapper Sean 'Diddy' Combs and the suspected health care CEO assassin Luigi Mangione have decided on a similar defense strategy: Hire an Agnifilo. Or two.
Russia's Putin apologizes to Azerbaijan over 'tragic' airliner crash
Russia's President Vladimir Putin on Saturday apologized to Azerbaijan's leader for what the Kremlin called a 'tragic incident' over Russia in which an Azerbaijan Airlines plane crashed after Russian air defenses were fired against Ukrainian drones.
Vancouver Island
-
New Canadians, non-traditional demographics boost minor hockey uptake in B.C.
Participation in hockey in British Columbia was struggling in 2021 — the pandemic had dealt a heavy blow to player registrations, and numbers had already been flagging before COVID-19 arrived.
-
'We're sending a clear message': B.C. prepares for home flipping tax amid criticism
Next week, when the calendars turn to 2025, the provincial government will begin imposing a 20-per-cent tax on all profits if a home is sold within a year of purchasing it.
-
Former B.C. lawyer disbarred for 2nd time over sexual harassment
A former lawyer who was convicted of sexual assault in 2020 and disbarred last year has been handed a second disbarment for sexual harassment of a different client.
Kelowna
-
B.C. team building 100 beaver 'starter homes' in the name of wetland preservation
More than 70 manmade beaver dams have been installed in Interior waterways since the B.C. Wildlife Federation project launched last year with the goal of building 100 dams by the end of 2025.
-
B.C. man charged with drug trafficking and weapons offences after CBSA investigation
A resident of B.C.'s Interior has been charged with weapon and drug trafficking offences after an investigation launched by border agents at Vancouver International Airport earlier this year.
-
B.C woman awarded nearly $750K in court case against contractor
A B.C. woman has been awarded nearly $750,000 in damages in a dispute with a contractor who strung her along for a year and a half and failed to complete a renovation, according to a recent court decision.
Edmonton
-
Edmonton street photographer captures moments and people one frame at a time
A local photographer who is passionate about capturing moments in one-hundredth of a second embraced many styles of his trade before landing on one which truly represents his mantra: street photography.
-
Uninspired Canada upset by Latvia in a shootout at world juniors
Eriks Mateiko scored the only goal of the shootout as Latvia stunned an alarmingly uninspired Canada 3-2 at the world junior hockey championship Friday.
-
'Way more expensive this year': Canadians feeling post-Christmas, Boxing Day spending squeeze
As the holiday rush starts to slow, stress from holiday spending starts to grow.
Calgary
-
Calgary Skyview MP George Chahal joins growing chorus of Liberals calling for Trudeau to step down
Calgary Liberal MP George Chahal has publicly released letters he sent to the Liberal caucus and president of the Liberal Party of Canada, calling on them to begin the process of moving on from Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.
-
Calgary Boxing Day crash victim identified, mother and sister still in hospital
A nine-year-old girl has died in hospital after the vehicle she was in was struck by a driver in a stolen vehicle fleeing from police.
-
Uninspired Canada upset by Latvia in a shootout at world juniors
Eriks Mateiko scored the only goal of the shootout as Latvia stunned an alarmingly uninspired Canada 3-2 at the world junior hockey championship Friday.
Lethbridge
-
Hurricanes trade for Seattle power forward Jordan Gustafson as second half of WHL season set to go
The Lethbridge Hurricanes are once again making roster moves, announcing a major trade Friday morning for an impactful power forward.
-
2024 second-highest visitation season for Waterton Lakes National Park
Visitation records at Waterton Lakes National Park were broken in 2024, with the year marking the second-busiest on record.
-
Lethbridge teen found dead outside business on Boxing Day
Lethbridge police are investigating the suspicious death of a 13-year-old boy, whose body was found outside a business in the city's south side on Dec. 26.
Winnipeg
-
The most-read stories on CTV Winnipeg in 2024
Historic events, community pride and significant losses dominated headlines in Manitoba in 2024. Here’s a list of the most-read stories of each month of 2024 on CTV News Winnipeg.
-
Police search for suspect in fatal assault
Winnipeg police are searching for a suspect after a man was fatally assaulted early Friday morning.
-
2 transported to hopsital in 3 unrelated stabbings
Two people were transported to hospital Friday evening following three unrelated stabbings within five hours.
Regina
-
Moose Jaw Police Service asks public to help locate 89-year-old man
The Moose Jaw Police Service (MJPS) is asking the public for help in locating an 89-year-old Moose Jaw resident who was last seen on Dec. 25, 2024.
-
Regina police chief says new initiatives to enhance community safety will come in 2025
Looking back after one year in his new role as the chief of the Regina Police Service, Farooq Hassan Sheikh is highlighting challenges the city faces, what has worked during his tenure and what can be done to improve policing in 2025.
-
'Something that connected us all': For 53 years, Sask. family celebrates holidays with street hockey game
For over 50 years, Stephen Lentzos and his family have celebrated Christmas Day with a street hockey game.
Saskatoon
-
The thrill is gone from Boxing Week shopping, Saskatoon residents say
Christmas has come and gone for most people, but the shopping hype continues as some get out of the house to take in the post-Christmas scene.
-
Police made two arrests following a shooting in Saskatoon
A swift response from Saskatoon police led to the arrest of a man and woman following a reported shooting Friday afternoon.
-
Saskatoon fire crews battle house fire
Saskatoon firefighters responded to a house fire on the 100 block of Klassen Crescent Friday afternoon.
Toronto
-
One person injured, suspect charged with arson following Etobicoke apartment fire
A suspect has been charged with arson after a two-alarm fire at an Etobicoke apartment complex early Saturday morning left one person with injuries.
-
Motorcyclist dead after 2-vehicle crash in Stouffville, Ont.: police
A motorcyclist is dead following a two-vehicle crash in Stouffville, Ont., police say.
-
Trudeau, Carney push back over Trump's ongoing 51st state comments
Two senior members of the federal cabinet were in Florida Friday pushing Canada's new $1.3 billion border plan with members of Donald Trump's transition team, a day after Prime Minister Justin Trudeau himself appeared to finally push back at the president-elect over his social media posts about turning Canada into the 51st state.
Montreal
-
Here are the changes coming to Quebec in 2025
With the new year just days away, here is a look at the changes that are in store for Quebecers in 2025.
-
Friend of Quebec man killed in Florida boat explosion says his sister also injured
A childhood friend of the Quebec man killed in a Florida boat explosion earlier this week says one of the victim's sisters was among the other six passengers injured in the blast.
-
Cyprus-flagged ship MV MACCOA remains stuck near Verchères
The MV MACCOA, a cargo ship registered in Cyprus, that ran aground on Christmas Eve in the St. Lawrence River near Verchères, Que., was still trapped on Saturday, after the Friday’s attempt to refloat it failed.
Ottawa
-
G2 driver stopped going more than 100 km/h over the speed limit on Hwy. 401 in eastern Ontario
A 17-year-old driver is facing charges after being caught speeding and driving dangerously on Highway 401 in eastern Ontario Friday evening, according to the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP).
-
TC Energy says early morning gas leak near Cornwall, Ont. resolved
A gas leak that happened at a compressor station near Cornwall, Ont. Saturday morning has been controlled, according to TC Energy.
-
FREEZING RAIN WARNING
FREEZING RAIN WARNING Freezing rain warning in effect for Ottawa this Saturday
Environment Canada says a freezing rain warning is in effect for Ottawa this Saturday.
Atlantic
-
One dead in two-vehicle collision in Sackville, N.B.
One person has died following a two-vehicle collision in Sackville, N.B., Friday.
-
'Nobody should have to go through that': N.B. family grieving father, daughter killed in crash
A New Brunswick family is grieving the loss of a father and daughter in a crash.
-
Man found dead inside tent in Dartmouth, police investigating
Halifax Regional Police is investigating a sudden death in Dartmouth, N.S.
London
-
St. Thomas fraud victim loses nearly $100K to job scam
According to police, the victim was investing money into a company that they believed they were employed by for over a month.
-
Power restored in east London following outage, police investigating crash
A reported two vehicle collision in the area of Adelaide Street and Hamilton Road shut down many roads over a large area while emergency crews investigated Friday night.
-
Ending the year with above seasonal temperatures
Warmer conditions are expected in the London, Ont. region this weekend, with the high forecast in the double digits.
Kitchener
-
Trudeau, Carney push back over Trump's ongoing 51st state comments
Two senior members of the federal cabinet were in Florida Friday pushing Canada's new $1.3 billion border plan with members of Donald Trump's transition team, a day after Prime Minister Justin Trudeau himself appeared to finally push back at the president-elect over his social media posts about turning Canada into the 51st state.
-
Sportscaster Greg Gumbel dies from cancer at age 78
Greg Gumbel, a longtime CBS sportscaster who broke barriers during his career calling some of the biggest sporting events, has died from cancer, according to a statement from his family released by the network on Friday. He was 78.
-
Fire rips through former Peter Hay Knife Company building in Cambridge
Emergency responders were called to a fire in Cambridge on Thursday as flames ripped through the building that formerly belonged to the Peter Hay Knife Company.
Northern Ontario
-
Hwy. 11 reopens after being closed for more than 24-hours after a five-vehicle crash
Highway 11 has reopened after a serious collision involving five vehicles closed the roadway between Golf Course Drive in New Liskeard and Highway 66 in Kenogami on Friday morning.
-
Trudeau, Carney push back over Trump's ongoing 51st state comments
Two senior members of the federal cabinet were in Florida Friday pushing Canada's new $1.3 billion border plan with members of Donald Trump's transition team, a day after Prime Minister Justin Trudeau himself appeared to finally push back at the president-elect over his social media posts about turning Canada into the 51st state.
-
Five southern Ont. hunters fined $37K for moose hunt offences in northern Ont.
A multi-year moose hunting investigation resulted in five people being convicted of moose hunting offences and fined a total of $37,000, plus $9,250 in victim surcharges.
N.L.
-
Icebreaker on hand in Labrador to guide season's last freight arrivals by ferry
A Canadian Coast Guard icebreaker is in central Labrador until Saturday to guide the Kamutik W ferry on its last freight deliveries of the season.
-
Whooping cough in Canada: Outbreaks or case increases reported in these provinces
Canadian health officials say they're seeing spikes in whooping cough cases in parts of the country as the U.S. deals with case numbers not seen in more than a decade.
-
Her son needed help with addiction. Instead, he's spending Christmas in N.L. jail.
As Gwen Perry prepares for a Christmas without contact from her son, who is locked inside a notorious St. John's, N.L., jail, she wants people to understand that many inmates need help, not incarceration.
