Worker put on unpaid leave for refusing to get vaccinated was not fired, B.C. court rules
A B.C. accountant who sued her employer over its mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy has had her claim dismissed.
Deepk Parmar's civil claim against Tribe Management Inc. alleged that the company "constructively dismissed" her when it placed her on unpaid leave for three months for failing to comply with the policy when it was implemented in late November 2021.
In a decision issued last week, B.C. Supreme Court Justice Heather MacNaughton concluded that Parmar's leave of absence did not amount to a constructive dismissal.
Instead, the judge concluded Tribe's decision to implement a mandatory vaccination policy was "a reasonable and lawful response to the uncertainty created by the COVID-19 pandemic based on the information that was then available to it."
THE POLICY
According to the court decision, Tribe is a publicly traded property management company that acquired Gateway Property Management in the summer of 2021. Parmar had been employed by Gateway since 2003, working her way up to a senior management position in the accounting department, which she continued to hold when Tribe acquired the company.
Before and after the acquisition, MacNaughton wrote, Parmar was a valued employee and there were no issues with her job performance.
After the COVID-19 pandemic began, Parmar began working from home, though the nature of her job required being present in the office periodically to sign cheques and fulfill other duties, according to the court decision.
"There is no dispute that Ms. Parmar carefully observed or exceeded all of the public health requirements while she was in the Tribe office," MacNaughton wrote.
As the pandemic evolved and vaccines became more widely available, the judgment indicates, Tribe asked workers to disclose their vaccination status and found that 84 per cent of its more than 200 employees were vaccinated.
"(Tribe managers) regarded the 16 percent who were still unvaccinated (35 employees out of 220) as an unacceptably high number considering the risks of COVID-19 as they were then understood and being presented by public health and in the media," MacNaughton wrote.
The company announced its mandatory vaccination policy in October 2021. By the Nov. 24, 2021, deadline, only Parmar and one other employee remained unvaccinated, according to the judgment.
THE OBJECTIONS
Tribe's mandatory vaccination policy allowed exemptions for religious or medical reasons, but Parmar did not claim either, according to MacNaughton's decision.
Rather, in the lead-up to the policy's implementation, Parmar spoke with supervisors to inquire whether vaccination would be "a condition of employment." She expressed concern about what MacNaughton described as "severe health complications" she had seen family members develop after receiving their shots.
Specifically, according to the decision, Parmar's father developed severe headaches, "brain fog, confusion, seizure-like episodes, shortness of breath, and overall weakness making it difficult to get out of bed." Her aunt experienced "an endometriosis flare-up" and an unidentified family acquaintance "experienced numbness in her legs and was unable to walk for over a week" after vaccination.
MacNaughton noted that no evidence was presented connecting these symptoms to the COVID-19 vaccines. Nevertheless, Parmar believed there could be a causal connection and "was hesitant to get vaccinated for fear of negative side effects."
Tribe advised Parmar that there would be no exceptions to the mandatory vaccination policy, other than those for religious or medical reasons. The company declined to allow Parmar to work remotely most of the time and take rapid tests whenever she had to go into the office, according to the judgment.
Parmar was placed on unpaid leave on Nov. 24, 2021, and her communication with the company soon gave way to communication between lawyers.
"On Jan. 15, 2022, counsel for Tribe wrote to Ms. Parmar’s counsel indicating that so long as she remained unvaccinated, she would continue to be on leave, but that Tribe expected that she would return to work immediately once vaccinated or the (policy) was repealed or relaxed," MacNaughton wrote in her decision.
On Jan. 26, the same day she filed her lawsuit alleging constructive dismissal, Parmar resigned from Tribe, according to the judgment.
THE CONCLUSION
Parmar's lawsuit alleged that her employer's mandatory vaccination policy was unreasonable because it did not accommodate employees who were able to work from home "either entirely or almost entirely," MacNaughton wrote.
"The focus is on whether Tribe had bona fide business reasons, including safety reasons, for the (mandatory vaccination policy) and for placing Ms. Parmar on an unpaid leave of absence for failing to comply with it," the judge wrote. "The issue is not whether the MVP was a perfect policy, but whether it was a reasonable approach when implemented, given the uncertainties then presented by the pandemic."
After discussing what was known about COVID-19 at the time the policy was being considered and implemented, MacNaughton concluded that the policy was reasonable.
She cited the similar policies that were in place for federal and provincial public service workers at the time, as well as the BC Vaccine Card program, which required proof of vaccination to engage in many activities in the province.
"I accept that it is extraordinary for an employer to enact a workplace policy that impacts an employee’s bodily integrity, but in the context of the extraordinary health challenges posed by the global COVID-19 pandemic, such policies are reasonable," MacNaughton concluded.
"They do not force an employee to be vaccinated. What they do force is a choice between getting vaccinated, and continuing to earn an income, or remaining unvaccinated, and losing their income. Ms. Parmar made her choice based on what appears to have been speculative information about potential risks."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
American millionaire Jonathan Lehrer denied bail after being charged with killing Canadian couple
American millionaire Jonathan Lehrer, one of two men charged in the killings of a Canadian couple in Dominica, has been denied bail.
LeBlanc says he plans to run in next election, under Trudeau's leadership
Cabinet minister Dominic LeBlanc says he plans to run in the next election as a candidate under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's leadership, amid questions about his rumoured interest in succeeding his longtime friend for the top job.
Sports columnist apologizes for 'oafish' comments directed at Caitlin Clark. The controversy isn’t over
A male columnist has apologized for a cringeworthy moment during former University of Iowa superstar and college basketball’s highest scorer Caitlin Clark’s first news conference as an Indiana Fever player.
U.S. vetoes a widely supported UN resolution backing full membership for Palestine
The United States has vetoed a widely backed UN resolution that would have paved the way for full United Nations membership for the state of Palestine.
Grandparent scam suspects had ties to Italian organized crime, police allege
A group of suspects that allegedly defrauded seniors across Ontario and other parts of Canada using a so-called emergency grandparent scam appear to have ties to 'Italian traditional organized crime,' according to an investigator involved in the OPP-led probe.
Health Canada to change sperm donor screening rules for men who have sex with men
Health Canada will change its longstanding policy restricting gay and bisexual men from donating to sperm banks in Canada, CTV News has learned. The federal health agency has adopted a revised directive removing the ban on gay, bisexual and other men who have sex with men, effective May 8.
Prince Harry formally confirms he is now a U.S. resident
Prince Harry, the son of King Charles III and fifth in line to the British throne, has formally confirmed he is now a U.S. resident.
Cat found on Toronto Pearson airport runway 3 days after going missing
Kevin the cat has been reunited with his family after enduring a harrowing three-day ordeal while lost at Toronto Pearson International Airport earlier this week.
N.L. gardening store revives 19th century seed-packing machine
Technology from the 19th century has been brought out of retirement at a Newfoundland gardening store, as staff look for all the help they can get to fill orders during a busy season.