WestJet ordered to pay passengers $2K after offering only $16 for flight diversion
B.C.’s Civil Resolution Tribunal has ordered WestJet to refund a family in full for their diverted flight and compensate them for associated costs.
The passengers, referred to as RA, SB and MB in the decision because MB is a child, were on a flight from Hawaii to Vancouver in April 2023 when it was diverted to Victoria due to smoke from a volcano, according to the tribunal.
The applicants claimed that WestJet agreed to refund their flights, but later refused to do so, and that the airline also agreed to pay for their hotel, travel and food expenses that resulted from the flight change, but only reimbursed part of the costs.
In his decision dated Sept. 17, tribunal member Peter Mennie was tasked with ruling whether WestJet owed the group a further $430.80 for hotel, travel and food costs and whether it owed $1,395.18 as a refund for the flights. He ultimately ruled WestJet must pay both.
The flight
After the family landed in Victoria the evening of April 13, 2023, they received an email from WestJet with three options: take a flight at 12 p.m. from Victoria to Vancouver, choose a different flight, or request a refund for the “flight-only itinerary.” They chose the refund, and WestJet sent an email confirming that request was being processed.
The decision says the group followed up with WestJet multiple times on the matter and received contradictory responses, and an employee eventually told them their refund wasn’t approved.
According to the decision, WestJet argued that the family is only entitled to $16.17 for their flights, because it says it’s only required to refund the “unused portion of the applicants’ tickets.”
WestJet calculated that the distance from Hawaii to Victoria was 98.84 per cent of the total route from Hawaii to Vancouver, and therefore the “unused portion” of the group’s tickets amounted to 1.16 per cent of the total ticket cost, or $16.17.
“WestJet argues that it never guaranteed a refund amount in its email to the applicants so it should only pay what it must under the (air passenger protection regulations),” the decision reads.
The passengers, meanwhile, argued that WestJet’s email offered a full refund, not just for the “unused portion” of their tickets.
“I agree with the applicants that the plain and ordinary meaning of a refund of the ‘flight-only itinerary’ is the full cost of the applicants’ flights. So, I find that WestJet’s email offered to refund the full cost of the applicants’ flights,” Mennie wrote.
WestJet also argued its refund offer was not enforceable because the group didn’t give something valuable to make the contract so, and the tribunal disagreed.
“WestJet provided three options and the applicants chose a refund. In doing so, the applicants gave up their right to a second flight. This was a detriment to the applicants and a benefit to WestJet which no longer had to fly the applicants to Vancouver. I find that this was good consideration which makes WestJet’s refund offer enforceable,” Mennie said.
The hotel, travel and food
The applicants said a WestJet employee on the plane told them to go to the airline desk in Victoria, as there were hotel rooms reserved for families with young children.
“The applicants say they and other families with young children waited over an hour at the WestJet desk, which was not staffed. At around 12:30 a.m., a second WestJet employee arrived and told the applicants that there were no hotel rooms so they should book their own accommodation,” the decision reads.
That employee reportedly told the family WestJet would reimburse their expenses – something the airline did not deny in its submissions. The passengers ultimately paid $784.90 for a hotel room, meals and taxis.
WestJet reimbursed the family $354.10 for those costs, citing airline policies as the reason they did not give the full amount.
The airline argued regulations do not require it to reimburse hotel, travel and food costs if the delay is due to causes outside of its control.
“(WestJet) says it paid $354.10 as a gesture of goodwill to partially reimburse the applicants,” the decision says.
However, Mennie reasoned that the WestJet employee promised the family that they would be compensated for the costs, without mentioning any policy limitations, and the applicants accepted that offer, and therefore “WestJet is bound by its employee’s statement and must reimburse the applicants’ costs.”
WestJet also brought up that it didn’t want to pay the costs as that would “make it an insurer for passengers regardless of whether the delay was within its control,” but Mennie said if WestJet wants to avoid paying in full for things like hotels and food it needs to be explicit with its passengers.
In the end, the tribunal ordered WestJet to pay $430.80 for the remaining costs and $1,395.18 for the flight tickets. Added up with pre-judgement interest and CRT fees, the applicants received $2,080.81 in total.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING Rescuers race to free people trapped by Hurricane Helene after storm kills at least 35 in 4 states
Hurricane Helene left an enormous path of destruction across Florida and the entire southeastern U.S. on Friday, killing at least 35 people in four states, snapping trees like twigs, tearing apart homes and sending rescue crews on desperate missions to save people from floodwaters.
Family of man killed by Calgary police issues statement
The family of Jon Wells, a man killed by Calgary police earlier this month, say they are seeking time to grieve their loss.
CSIS says a former parliamentarian may have worked on behalf of a foreign government
A former parliamentarian is suspected of 'having worked to influence parliamentary business' on behalf of an unnamed foreign government, Canada's spy service told a federal inquiry Friday.
P.E.I. shellfish festival gastrointestinal illness outbreak largest in province's history: health officer
More than 550 symptomatic people responded to an online questionnaire about a gastrointestinal illness at a Prince Edward Island shellfish festival last weekend.
Maggie Smith, scene-stealing actor famed for Harry Potter and 'Downton Abbey,' dies at 89
Maggie Smith, the masterful, scene-stealing actor who won an Oscar for 1969 film 'The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie' and gained new fans in the 21st century as the dowager Countess of Grantham in 'Downton Abbey' and Professor Minerva McGonagall in the Harry Potter films, died Friday. She was 89.
What's 'chroming'? Experts explain the dangerous social media trend among youths
Chroming, or getting high via inhaling hydrocarbons by misusing a variety of legal products, is trending among adolescents, and it sometimes ends in death.
What is open and closed this National Day for Truth and Reconciliation
This Monday, Sept. 30 is the National Day for Truth and Reconciliation (NDTR), a federal statutory holiday and day of remembrance for the Indigenous children who never came home from Canadian residential schools, as well as those who survived them.
Live hurricane tracker: follow Helene's path on this interactive map
Here is an interactive hurricane map using live tracking data from the NOAA National Hurricane Center (NHC), following Hurricane Helene's observed and forecasted paths.
Israel says it struck Hezbollah's headquarters in huge explosion that shook Lebanon's capital
The Israeli military said Friday it struck the headquarters of Hezbollah in Beirut, where a series of massive explosions leveled multiple buildings and sent clouds of orange and black smoke into the sky in the biggest blasts to hit the Lebanese capital in the past year. At least two people were killed and dozens were wounded, Lebanon’s health ministry said.