Vancouver Tenants Union opposes controversial Broadway Plan
Vancouver Tenants Union opposes controversial Broadway Plan
A so-called “resistance movement” was launched at Vancouver City Hall Monday by those opposed to a controversial plan to dramatically densify the Broadway corridor.
Called the Broadway Plan, the 30-year proposal aims to create much-needed housing, but those who already live in the area are concerned they’ll be displaced.
Monday's event was hosted by the Vancouver Tenants Union, which released the results of a survey it conducted with those living along the corridor back in fall 2021.
The group surveyed 293 households across 41 purpose-built rental buildings.
“While the median market rental price is known, there is currently no data collected on tenured rental rates in B.C.,” a report from the group said.
The VTU said the data it collected points to a large rent gap between the median current rent tenants surveyed are paying, compared to the median market rental price.
As part of the survey, the VTU calculated the difference between the maximum current rent in a building versus the minimum current rent, calling it the “Delta Rent.”
When averaged across all buildings survey it, found a rent increase of:
- $243/month for studios
- $431/month for one bedrooms
- $421/month for two bedrooms
“In other words, today, the average landlord of a building in our survey area could expect an 18-20 per cent increase in income on their lowest paid units if they’re able to find some pretense to evict that tenant,” the VTU's statement said.
According to the survey, the difference between the median market rent and the median surveyed rent is:
- Studio - the median market rate is $1,925 and the median surveyed rent is $1,167
- One bedroom - the median market rate is $2,200 and the median surveyed rent is $1,379
- Two bedroom- the median market rate is $3,200 and the median surveyed rent is $1,885
“A landlord can expect a 60 to 70 per cent general increase in rental income across all units if they redevelop their building and replace all of their tenants. Think of it as the financial incentive to demoevict," said Mark Gharibnavaz, organizer with the VTU.
One-in-five survey respondents said that their current rent is unaffordable to them, and more than half said they would not be able to remain in their neighbourhood if they were evicted.
“There are some exciting possibilities when it comes to building housing and communities along public transit, but in the hands of real estate interests it is a weapon against poor and working-class communities across the city,” said Gharibnavaz.
However, Mayor Kennedy Stewart is promising the strongest renter protections in Canada.
If approved, the plan would redevelop the Broadway corridor, which is slated to be home to the new Broadway Subway by 2025, into a second downtown over the coming decades.
The proposal would allow for residential towers up to 40 storeys tall, adding housing for an additional 50,000 people.
Stewart has promised any displacement would be temporary, and residents would be compensated or given the right to move into the new units at or below current rents.
The mayor would not guarantee they would be the same size units.
However, Stewart said the city would "see" about getting people who are living in over-crowded spaces into larger units.
The mayor said the builders will also have to pay for the renter's moving costs and any difference in rent at their temporary accommodations.
The lower rental rates are tied to the units themselves.
The CEO of LandlordBC said the plan to have developers off-set some of the costs to keep rents low is not feasible.
“The basic economics of rental housing … are hugely challenging, both in terms of operation and in building new rental, and it's increasingly becoming difficult to build new rental with still high construction costs, land costs and interest rates going up,” David Hutniak told CTV News.
“The conversation needs to shift,” he said. “This can't be done simply on the backs of the owners of these buildings and the developers of these buildings. This has to be addressed in the broader context of taxpayers and we need to share the cost of doing this.”
In the city’s draft proposal, the report said 83 per cent of the purpose-built rentals are at least 50 years old.
If the Broadway Plan goes ahead, it would be 2050 before the vision is actualized.
Hutniak said there should also be a focus on upgrading or replacing the aging rentals.
“They're going to be at the end of their functional life before the Broadway area plan runs its 30-year course. So we need to have a conversation about how how do we protect renters, but how do we ensure that there's a business case to maintain these old buildings to redevelop them to ensure that we have the housing supply that we need for both current and future renters,” he said.
Current residents have raised concerns about how those protections will be enforced if developers will buy into the idea.
But Gharibnavaz is skeptical the plan will actually protect the interests of renters.
“When city planners and politicians in an election year tell you that no tenants will pay any more rent after redevelopment based off of their proposed policies, do not believe them,” he said.
Stewart made a final pitch in support of the plan last Thursday.
He campaigned for more rental housing back in 2018 and it appears to remain a key part of his campaign with just five months until the next municipal election.
The draft plan will go to council Wednesday for a vote.
Vancouver Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
As NATO prepares to embark on the greatest overhaul of the alliance’s deterrence capabilities since the Cold War at a leaders’ summit in Spain, Canada’s role in the new defence strategy remains uncertain.
A Nexus card is supposed to help put low-risk Canadians on the fast track when crossing the U.S. border, but at least 330,000 Canadians aren’t sure when their applications will be processed.
Canada Day celebrations are making a return after two years of scaled-down festivities because of the COVID-19 pandemic, but some Canadians hoping to catch a traditional parade may be out of luck.
Six police officers are in hospital with gunshot wounds and two suspects have been killed following a shooting at a bank in Saanich, B.C., on Tuesday.
Witnesses recount what they saw after police officers engaged in a shooting with armed suspects at a bank in Saanich, B.C., on Tuesday morning. Two suspects are dead and six officers are in hospital with gunshot wounds.
The mastermind of an elaborate Ponzi scheme that cheated hundreds of people of tens of millions of dollars was sentenced Tuesday in a Barrie, Ont., courtroom. Charles Debono has been behind bars since his arrest in 2020 for his role in one of the largest Ponzi schemes in Canadian history.
Tensions were high in India's western Udaipur city Wednesday, a day after police arrested two Muslim men accused of slitting a Hindu tailor's throat in a brutal attack that highlights a dramatic escalation of communal violence in a country riven by deep religious polarization.
Airbnb has codified a global policy that prohibits guests from hosting parties or events on all listed properties.
Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy accused Russia on Tuesday of becoming 'a terrorist' state carrying out 'daily terrorist acts' and urged Russia's expulsion from the United Nations.
"Officers initially detained the driver for impaired driving by alcohol, however their focus quickly diverted after noting that he was literally holding in his hands two bricks of suspected cocaine," said Nanaimo RCMP in a release Tuesday.
The premier of British Columbia has announced plans to step down, but will remain on the job until the provincial NDP can choose his successor.
Alberta Finance Minister Jason Nixon says the final number on the 2021-22 fiscal year, which ended on March 31, is a $3.9-billion surplus.
'Appreciation and gratitude': Toronto couple thank Calgary fire crew for treating and transporting daughter to hospital
A Toronto couple expressed appreciation and gratitude for the fire fighters who treated and transported their three-year-old daughter to Children's hospital over the weekend.
The Calgary Airport Authority and its partners are preparing for the busiest summer travel season since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Parents of 2012 HUB Mall murder victim fear Supreme Court decision could lead to shorter sentence for son's killer
The Supreme Court of Canada struck down a law passed by the former Stephen Harper Conservatives that allows a judge to increase parole ineligibility periods for offenders who commit multiple murders. Now there’s fear it could mean sentence “discounts” for other mass murderers.
Edmonton is moving forward with a plan to improve snow and ice clearing on roads and sidewalks, but it could cost homeowners an extra three per cent in taxes over three years.
One person is dead after a crash north of Redwater on Tuesday.
A mother of three children is speaking out after spending a night on the floor of Toronto Pearson Airport with her young kids and six-month-old baby in a weekend of travel that she says cost her most than $1,000 in unexpected expenses.
A longtime Toronto legislator has been named interim leader of Ontario's New Democrats as the Official Opposition party gears up for a leadership contest.
What was supposed to be a fun weekend trip with friends to Arizona has turned into a nightmarish five-day, “suitcase scavenger hunt” for Toronto resident Jehaanara Kurji.
A coroner's report released Tuesday is calling on Quebec to teach new drivers to open their car doors with their right hand in order to prevent dooring incidents with cyclists.
A 26-year-old man has been ordered to undergo a mental health assessment after prosecutors allege he fatally stabbed his stepfather and seriously wounded three others this weekend. The victim was lawyer Raymond Hebert.
A multi-vehicle collision near Joliette has killed one person and sent several others to hospital, police say.
Two people were taken to hospital in critical condition late Tuesday afternoon after vehicle and scooter collided in St. Boniface.
A new invasive species in Clear Lake has Parks Canada taking steps to prevent damage to the aquatic ecosystem.
A program giving inmates a chance to get an education while serving time in Manitoba’s Stony Mountain Institution is looking to expand, according to the Correctional Service of Canada.
Saskatoon police say an investigation is ongoing, amidst a large police presence on Avenue J South between 21st and 22nd street west.
One of the longest-running measures of the pandemic was lifted during Monday's city council meeting.
Prairie Spirt School Division says it will struggle to cover inflationary costs such as gas in the coming school year.
The Government of Saskatchewan is gearing up for a joint COVID-19 booster and influenza vaccination program in the fall.
A new $60 million YWCA Centre for Women and Families was announced in Regina on Tuesday.
The Saskatchewan Roughriders are dealing with familiar territory after the loss of Shaq Evans due to injury.
A scathing letter from an RCMP communications manager released today says RCMP Commissioner Brenda Lucki referred to direct pressure from the federal public safety minister to release firearm details in the days after the Nova Scotia mass shooting.
Several workers are injured after part of a building under construction collapsed in Moncton, N.B., Tuesday morning.
The body of an 82-year-old woman who was reported missing from Sainte-Anne-de-Kent, N.B., has been found, according to RCMP in New Brunswick.
London fire crews were able to knock down a blaze and save a family dog late Tuesday night.
Huron County OPP are on scene of a serious single vehicle car crash southwest of Hensall
'A little bit dumbfounded': Family questions why siblings can’t be together at same French immersion school
With limited spaces in French immersion programs, the Thames Valley District School Board is finding itself having to remind families there’s not enough room for everyone.
On Tuesday, the federal government announced $2.6 million for improvements to taxiways, a runway and lighting at Sudbury's airport.
Five projects in North Bay are receiving money from the federal government through the New Horizons for Seniors Program.
A $2 million operation designed to help startup businesses in Sudbury has opened its doors. It’s being described as a hub for innovation, creative thinking and collaboration.
The family of a Black four-year-old who was removed from school by police has filed a lawsuit against the Waterloo Catholic District School Board seeking $1 million in damages for what they says is the board's discrimination and negligence.
Every morning, when Karli Chomick would drop her children Savanna and Ryder off at St. Timothy Catholic Elementary School in Kitchener, she would do the same thing: give them a hug and a kiss, then tell them to be kind.
Ira Needles Boulevard is closed between Highway 7/8 and Highview Drive.