Time for an equity tax? Experts look for solutions to increasingly unaffordable housing
From the speculation and vacancy tax to the foreign buyers tax, B.C.'s current measures designed to improve housing affordability haven't managed to slow a market that's often considered a cash cow. Now, a West Coast think tank argues a surtax on equity may be part of the solution.
In a study funded by the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation and conducted by Generation Squeeze, the authors collaborated with various stakeholders and found that while many homeowners want prices to stay high, the ability of future generations to afford homes is a common concern.
University professor Paul Kershaw, who heads up the group, said the need for more action to slow housing prices is evident.
"We only need to look at the most recent evaluations from B.C. Assessment to show us the once-again skyrocketing prices of housing in this province," he told CTV News in an interview.
That makes it tougher for those working hard to get into the market. Generation Squeeze came up with several possible solutions, such as having federal agencies ramp up the building of low-carbon co-operatives and affordable housing. Another idea is to allow mortgage-holders who feel they're in too deep to sell their property at fair market value to an independent agency, which would then create multiple units. The owners would then be guaranteed a rental spot at 30 per cent of their income.
But the idea garnering the most attention is the one proposing a new tax.
Kershaw said the Price on Housing Equity would target the value above $1 million in the hopes that could slow the market.
"The primary purpose of the Price on Housing Equity is to try and slow down home prices, to just capture the idea that to restore affordability for all, we need home prices to stall so that earnings have a chance to catch up," he said.
The surtax would be a sliding scale -- between 0.2 per cent and one per cent -- added to homes valued at more than $1 million, and applying only to the portion above six figures. A $1.2 million property would get dinged $400 a year, and owners could also defer payments until the home is sold.
Kershaw admitted the approach would impact the ability of Canadians to count on housing as their primary retirement investment, and that would take a lot of convincing.
"It's a cultural issue," he said. But is it an issue that political leaders are ready to tackle?
Cut red tape instead, critics say
The Canadian Taxpayers Federation was quick to pan the idea.
Federal director Franco Terrazzano told CTV News, "You build homes with hammers, not tax hikes."
He argued part of the affordability problem is red tape and taxes, which can add thousands of dollars to the construction of a single-family home. Terrazzano said that's where governments should start, because reducing those fees would lead to more supply.
"Many Canadians rely on the proceeds from the sale of their home to fund their golden years, to fund their retirement, so this would mean a lot of pain for those Canadians," Terrazzano added.
He noted younger Canadians may also choose to upgrade their homes when expanding their families.
Generation Squeeze said the amount that would be collected with an equity tax, estimated to be in the billions of dollars, could help fund affordable homes. In a press release, CTF claimed that amount of tax revenue "would cover the spending of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s government for less than five days."
Response from governments
CMHC, which funded the study, pointed out neither it nor Ottawa are required to adopt the proposals in the report. Both the Liberals and Conservatives rejected the idea of an equity tax in the last election.
Kershaw believes the tax could be implemented provincially. The study estimates about 21 per cent of homes in B.C. are valued at over $1 million.
The Finance Ministry said the report would need to be studied, but noted the idea of a surtax was similar to the school tax previously implemented by the NDP. "The proposal for a surtax on the highest value homes appears similar to the Additional School Tax implemented in 2018 as part of Homes for BC, our 30-point housing plan. As part of this plan, we increased the annual school tax and the property transfer tax on residential properties worth over $3 million," the ministry said in a statement.
The province said the tax has raised more than $300 million for affordable housing, and that the government has spent nearly $2.8 billion in affordable housing projects since the housing plan was implemented.
Still, Kershaw believes the issue isn't about taxes, but how we view homes.
"Do we want housing to be a place to call home? Or do we want it to be a good investment strategy?" he said. "We have been ambivalent or complacent about that question for far too long."
The provincial budget is due Tuesday, Feb. 22, and it's unclear whether it could include more measures to help address affordability.
The Finance Ministry's statement said there is "more to come."
"We will keep working with municipalities to streamline development processes and get homes built faster, and will be introducing a new cooling off period this spring and looking at other potential measures to ensure prospective buyers are protected in a volatile market," it said.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
CRA no longer requiring 'bare trust' reporting in 2023 tax return
The Canada Revenue Agency announced Thursday it will not require 'bare trust' reporting from Canadians that it introduced for the 2024 tax season, just four days before the April 2 deadline.
He didn't trust police but sought their help anyway. Two days later, he was dead
Jameek Lowery was among more than 330 Black people who died after police stopped them with tactics that aren’t supposed to be deadly, like physical restraint and use of stun guns, The Associated Press found.
Fluid in eye cells can 'boil' if you watch the eclipse without protection: expert
Millions of people in parts of Eastern and Atlantic Canada will be able to see the rare solar eclipse happening on April 8. But they should only look up if they have proper eye protection, experts say.
NEW More unauthorized products for skin, sexual enhancement, recalled: Here are the recalls of this week
Health Canada and the Canadian Food Inspection Agency recalled various items this week, including torches, beef biltong and unauthorized products related to skin care and sexual enhancement.
Where is the worst place for allergy sufferers in Canada?
The spring allergy season has started early in many parts of Canada, with high levels of pollen in some cities already. Experts weigh in on which areas have it worse so far this season.
Do these exercises for core strength if you can't stomach doing planks
Planks are one of the most effective exercises for strengthening your midsection, as they target all of your major core muscles: the transverse abdominis, rectus abdominis, external obliques and internal obliques. Yet despite the popularity of various 10-minute plank challenges, planking is actually one of the most dreaded core exercises, according to many fitness experts.
Grandparent scam: London, Ont., senior beats fraudsters not once, but twice
It was a typical Tuesday for Mabel Beharrell, 84, until she got the call that would turn her world upside down. Her teenaged grandson was in trouble and needed her help.
Angst and calls for resting places as Surrey, B.C., pet cemetery development continues
A single headstone is all that remains of dozens of markers for long-buried pets in a subdivision in Surrey’s Newton neighbourhood, where a half-acre parcel bears a large sign announcing the proposed construction of new homes.
Polar ice is melting and changing Earth's rotation. It's messing with time itself
One day in the next couple of years, everyone in the world will lose a second of their time. Exactly when that will happen is being influenced by humans, according to a new study, as melting polar ice alters the Earth’s rotation and changes time itself.