'A sign of a broken system': B.C. widow frustrated with 'slow' legal process in hit-and-run case
A B.C. widow says she's feeling frustrated by the 'slow' court system as she waits for the person charged in her husband's hit-and-run death to be tried.
Michelle Masala lay flowers Friday at the memorial on the side of the road where her husband had been cycling when he was fatally struck by a hit-and-run driver.
She said she'd heard a commotion at the time, but didn't know what was happening. Charles Masala died June 29, 2019, just blocks from his home near a trail head off Gaglardi Way in Burnaby.
“If I’d understood the significance of the sirens, I could have been here with him,” she told CTV News in her first interview since her husband died. “I didn’t find out until three hours later, and then he was gone.”
Monday would have been their sixth wedding anniversary.
In January of this year, 24-year-old Sumeet Mangat was charged with impaired operation causing death, dangerous operation causing death and failing to stop.
“The last two years have been difficult trying to figure out how to be a single mom while grieving through a pandemic with two small children,” said Masala. “Still quite often I expect him to come home.”
She said she's frustrated with the speed of the court process; how it took a year and a half to charge someone with her husband’s death and how, six months later, there is still no plea or trial date set.
“I want to move forward, I want to try and rebuild something with my kids,” explained Masala. “But we’re constantly being pulled back into the whole day (of the fatal crash) by being called by court, being called by police, waiting for a court date that doesn’t actually happen, and then having to sit and wait and tuck it aside again while we wait for the next date to come up.”
The next court appearance for Mangat is a pre-hearing conference scheduled for Aug. 19.
"These conferences are mandated by the court and must be held before a date is set either for a preliminary inquiry or a trial," said a spokesperson for the prosecution in an email.
"In cases where the Crown proceeds by indictment there is no requirement for a plea until the accused is before the trial court.”
The email goes on to say while the B.C. Prosecution Service tries to bring every case to trial in a timely manner, “some delays are unavoidable.”
Masala said she has been told a number of reasons for delays since charges were laid, including the pandemic, scheduling and logistics.
“If there’s not enough resources to deal with something that took somebody’s life, then that’s a sign of a broken system,” she said. “I’ve been dealing with the aftermath for two years, (the accused’s) been dealing with the aftermath for two years, it’s time to sort ourselves out at this point and not prolong it any further.”
Mangat’s defence lawyer, Paul McMurray, told CTV News it took a long time for the police to forward the report to Crown, and for Crown to approve charges. He also explained part of the delay is because the investigation is fairly substantial, and there’s a lot of information to be disclosed.
“I appreciate it’s not moving along as quickly as it might be, but it’s not moving along at glacial pace as some cases do,” said McMurray over the phone. “It’s not out of the ordinary.”
Masala said she’s not holding her breath that the next pre-hearing conference won’t also be delayed, adding she feels the system is not geared toward supporting families.
“There’s always a reason why it gets extended and none of it comes back to Charles’s rights, our rights as a family,” she said. “I full-heartedly believe that the police and the Crown, they’re doing the best that they can within the system that they have.”
In the meantime, Masala works hard to keep her husband’s memory alive for her kids.
“I talk about him. I talk about quirky things about him, like hot sauce is a big thing in our family, that my kids joke about putting hot sauce in my coffee because daddy loved hot sauce,” she said with a laugh.
“I try to keep the fun things about him, and also reinforce with them when we’re discussing the future, whatever that may look like, that they’re allowed to dream big because that was Charles’s thing.”
She described her husband as an excellent debater, who saw it almost as a sport to try to stump someone. He was also an avid cyclist.
“He always said that if he hadn’t been raised in rural Africa he probably would have been in the Tour de France. He loved, loved cycling,” said Masala.
She met Charles on a hiking trip organized through their church. She said it happened at random that she ended up in his car on the trip, and about a year later, they were married.
“It was just one of those super cheesy, love-at-first-sight deals,” said Masala.
Their daughter, now three, has his personality, she said.
“She’s a lot like her father. She’s got a lot of life to her, a lot of attitude and yeah, so much like him,” said Masala. “But she doesn’t remember him, so that’s a hard one.”
She said he was an engineer with two master's degrees and moved to Canada in 1991 from Zambia. His mother still lives there but Charles’s dad died before he found out about his son's death.
“I don’t know what happened that day because it’s not public record yet,” she said. “(It) was my husband’s life, those minutes were mine and I’m adamant in that argument -- in that those minutes, as his wife, were mine -- and I can’t have them yet. I don’t know what happened to him other than he was riding and he landed there.”
He always believed you can’t complain about something if you’re not going to do something about it, said Masala. She hopes by raising awareness about the court system’s short comings, it will be fixed.
“I just want him to be proud,” she said.
There’s a permanent memorial that’s been built on the side of the road where Charles died. A white bike painted with his birth country’s colours is there, along with photos reminding people he’s a father, son, brother, husband and friend, not just another hit-and-run victim.
Vancouver Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Health Canada has authorized brand name changes for three COVID-19 vaccines. The Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine will now be named Comirnaty, the Moderna vaccine will be named SpikeVax, and the AstraZeneca vaccine will be named Vaxzevria, Health Canada said in a tweet Thursday.
TRUTH TRACKER | Could a Conservative government close the border at Roxham Road?
In a video posted to his Twitter account Monday, Conservative Leader Erin O'Toole, in French, pledged to close the land border crossing at Roxham Road in Quebec where he says 'thousands of people crossed the border illegally' – a pledge experts say is complicated and misleading.
Vaccine mandate protesters' use of Nazi imagery and comparisons to the Holocaust is angering Jewish organizations.
A question at the English-language federal leaders' debate last week has become a major issue in Quebec, boosting the Bloc Quebecois in the polls and drawing criticism from Quebec politicians, federal party leaders and the province's media.
With less then a week until election day, former U.S. president Barack Obama has waded into the fray to bolster the campaign of Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau.
A new "high-speed" passenger ferry service is coming to Nanaimo, which will connect the city's downtown core with downtown Vancouver.
Norman, a large mastiff from Nanaimo that has been credited in saving the lives of at least 16 dogs with emergency blood donations, is now in need of help himself.
B.C. Health officials will release an update on the state the of the COVID-19 pandemic in the province on Thursday afternoon.
LIVE at 3:30
LIVE at 3:30 | Hinshaw, Yiu to give COVID-19 update Thursday afternoon
Alberta health officials will give a COVID-19 update Thursday afternoon, a day after the province introduced new restrictions and a vaccine passport.
Alberta doctors are imploring the province to take the pandemic more seriously in the wake of new restrictions and are calling out Premier Kenney for his claims that the COVID-19 virus was 'not predictable.'
A man was killed in northwest Calgary on Thursday when the truck he was working under fell on top of him.
LIVE at 3:30 | Hinshaw, Yiu to give COVID-19 update Thursday afternoon
If you live in Alberta and woke up extra early Thursday morning to print out your new vaccine status card, you may have noticed you can't… at least, not yet.
The teacher was employed at Secord Elementary School in Toronto at the time of his arrest.
Police seek eight suspects in violent protest outside 14 Division following clearing of homeless encampment
Police have arrested three people in connection with a violent protest that took place outside 14 Division following the clearing of a homeless encampment earlier this summer.
A spokesperson for the hospital said the man's condition "deteriorated rapidly."
The Legault government has rejected a motion that called for children to have the right to a childcare space.
Quebec's Ministry of Health reported Thursday that 782 more people have tested positive for COVID-19, and two more people have died due to the disease.
Manitoba public health officials reported 64 new COVID-19 cases on Thursday – including 36 unvaccinated cases, 20 fully vaccinated cases and eight partially vaccinated cases.
Manitobans will have a female premier for the first time.
A St. Boniface park could be getting a name change as its current one has been deemed offensive to Indigenous people in an application to the Welcoming Winnipeg Committee.
A Saskatchewan ICU doctor says the healthcare system is “stretched” and doctors have to make difficult calls as the number of COVID-19 cases rises.
Police are again asking for help in the search for four men wanted on Canada-wide warrants related to human trafficking charges.
Saskatchewan confirmed 439 new COVID-19 cases on Thursday, along with one new death.
Regina city council is pushing back its target date to require proof of vaccination from people entering city facilities.
Health officials in Nova Scotia are reporting 34 new cases of COVID-19 on Thursday, along with 20 recoveries, as the number of active cases in the province rises to 173.
P.E.I. reports seven new cases of COVID-19 related to elementary school outbreak Thursday; active cases rise to record 34
Health officials in Prince Edward Island are reporting seven new cases of COVID-19 on Thursday as the active number of cases in the province rises to 34 - the highest number of cases in the province since the pandemic began.
N.B. reports 51 new COVID-19 cases; 92 per cent of which are among people who are not fully vaccinated
New Brunswick Public Health reported 51 new cases of COVID-19 on Thursday, including 47 – or 92 per cent – among people who are not fully vaccinated.
Western University, which is investigating sexual misconduct allegations, will require student residents to take training sessions on sexual violence and consent as it works to address what it describes as a problematic campus culture.
The medical officer of health for the Middlesex London Health Unit (MLHU) isn’t concerned about the renaming of the COVID-19 vaccines in Canada
The Middlesex-London Health Unit (MLHU) is reporting 33 new COVID-19 cases Thursday, but no new deaths.
North Bay’s Jewish community disappointed by PPC candidate’s tweet comparing vaccine rules to Holocaust
Members of North Bay's Jewish community are disappointed in People’s Party of Canada candidate Greg Galante, who compared COVID-19 measures to the Holocaust.
A Sudbury court has sentenced Steffin Rees, 19, to 15 years in jail Thursday for a fatal stabbing in 2019 in downtown Sudbury.
Some residents at Finlandia Village in Greater Sudbury are in isolation after a staff member tested positive for COVID-19.
Health officials in Waterloo Region reported 35 new COVID-19 cases on Thursday.
Just over a week into the new school year, Waterloo Region’s school boards have released COVID-19 vaccination figures for their employees.
A man living in a Brantford retirement home has been charged with manslaughter in connection to the death of another resident at the home.