'Sleeping with the enemy': Mistrial in B.C. sex assault case over Crown dating paralegal
Scales of justice. (Shutterstock)
The B.C. Supreme Court has ordered a new trial for a man convicted of sexual assault after he learned his defence lawyer's paralegal was dating the Crown prosecutor during his trial.
Justice Veronica Jackson ruled last week in Courtenay, B.C., that Cameron Gagne should get a new trial because his lawyer, Eric Chesterley, and prosecutor Nicholas Grabe failed to tell the court about the relationship.
Gagne was found guilty of sexual assault by a jury in November 2023, and the judge's ruling said that at a hearing last March, Chesterley disclosed that he knew his paralegal had been dating the prosecutor, telling the court the relationship was not "entirely unknown" to him.
The ruling said Gagne was shocked to learn of the "romantic relationship" between the prosecutor and his lawyer's paralegal, who assisted Chesterley throughout the trial that began in October 2023.
Neither Gagne's current nor former lawyer responded to a request for comment.
In an emailed statement, the BC Prosecution Service said it is "reviewing the decision and will have no further comment" while the case is still before the court.
The service's statement said the next scheduled court date in the case is Dec. 16.
Jackson's decision said Gagne applied for a mistrial, claiming his trial was unfair due to a "miscarriage of justice" because neither his lawyer nor the prosecutor told him about the relationship.
The judge ordered a new trial for the man, finding the relationship was "concealed" from Gagne and not disclosed to the court, which she found to be "egregious" conduct that created "an appearance of unfairness."
"A reasonable and objective observer would consider it a betrayal and a fundamental breach of trial fairness for an accused to learn only after he has been convicted at trial that a member of his defence team had been, at least metaphorically, sleeping with the enemy, by being involved in a personal relationship with the Crown, a relationship known to both counsel, but concealed from him," Jackson's ruling concludes.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Dec. 3, 2024
Shopping Trends
The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at CTV News. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop. Read about us.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
'Hell on earth': Ottawa rapper TwoTiime among Canadians displaced by L.A. fires
Ottawa rapper Khalid Omar, who performs under the name TwoTiime, was forced to evacuate his Calabasas condo as wildfires tore through the Los Angeles area this week, leaving the studio where he records in ruins.
16 dead, 16 missing as fire crews try to corral Los Angeles blazes before winds return this week
The death toll from the wildfires ravaging the Los Angeles area rose to 16 as crews battled to cut off the spreading blazes before potentially strong winds return that could push the flames toward some of the city's most famous landmarks.
Alberta premier Danielle Smith meets with Trump at impromptu Mar-a-Lago visit
Alberta premier Danielle Smith met with President-elect Donald Trump Saturday at Mar-a-Lago in Florida.
Are there U.S. military bases and American troops in Canada?
The U.S. military has more than 165,000 troops deployed in over 170 countries and territories, including Canada.
Costco Canada accused of overcharging online shoppers in class-action lawsuit
Perrier Attorneys says Costco charged more for items online than in-store, a practice known as “double ticketing,” which is banned under the Competition Act.
Meet Franklin, the rescued tortoise who spent the last three months in a B.C. fridge
Franklin the tortoise has been in a fridge for the past 15 weeks.
Teen's road test halted by stunt driving charge
A 17-year-old driver failed their road test before it even began after being stopped by police in a community safety zone.
'He was a genius': Family remembers man who died waiting for care in Winnipeg ER
The sister of a man who died waiting for care in the emergency department of Winnipeg’s Health Sciences Centre (HSC) is remembering her late brother as an intelligent person with a bold personality
Former PM Chretien says Liberal party must move back to 'radical centre'
As the Liberal party searches for a new leader, former prime minister Jean Chretien says it's time for the party to move back to the "radical centre" to help its electoral fortunes.
Vancouver Island
-
B.C. fire crews sent to fight Los Angeles wildfire: forests minister
British Columbia’s forests minister says a crew from the province’s wildfire service left for California Saturday afternoon to help battle the wildfires ravaging the Los Angeles area.
-
Meet Franklin, the rescued tortoise who spent the last three months in a B.C. fridge
Franklin the tortoise has been in a fridge for the past 15 weeks.
-
Florence Girard was 55 pounds when she starved in home-share. Her sister wants change
The sister of a British Columbia woman with Down syndrome who starved to death in a Port Coquitlam home in 2018 says she believes more people will die if systemic changes aren't made to how people with developmental disabilities are treated.
Kelowna
-
West Kelowna fire chief says L.A. devastation a haunting reminder of B.C. blaze
The fire chief of a British Columbia community devastated by a fast-moving wildfire in 2023 says it's "haunting" to see similar circumstances playing out in Southern California.
-
1 hospitalized, residents displaced after Kelowna apartment fire
Firefighters knocked down a blaze on the third floor of a low-rise apartment building near downtown Kelowna Monday afternoon.
-
Lost skiers rescued off B.C. mountain
Search and rescue volunteers in B.C.’s Okanagan successfully reunited two skiers with their family Friday evening.
Edmonton
-
Alberta premier Danielle Smith meets with Trump at impromptu Mar-a-Lago visit
Alberta premier Danielle Smith met with President-elect Donald Trump Saturday at Mar-a-Lago in Florida.
-
Minister says dozens of firefighters from Alberta and B.C. to deploy in California
Emergency Preparedness Minister Harjit Sajjan says dozens of firefighters from Alberta and British Columbia will help fight wildfires in California, and the federal government is co-ordinating efforts with the provinces to deploy resources.
-
Outdoor tournament held in 'perfect setting' as part of Edmonton minor hockey week
A pond hockey tournament for players in the under-9 age category at Cattail Crossing Golf Club in west Edmonton was "the perfect setting" for the outdoor extravaganza.
Calgary
-
Alberta premier Danielle Smith meets with Trump at impromptu Mar-a-Lago visit
Alberta premier Danielle Smith met with President-elect Donald Trump Saturday at Mar-a-Lago in Florida.
-
Hit-and-run on Tsuut’ina First Nation critically injures two pedestrians
Tsuut'ina police need your help as officers investigate a hit and run that sent two people to hospital were they are listed in critical but stable condition.
-
Homicide investigation underway after man found dead in downtown Calgary
A homicide investigation is underway after a man was found dead early Sunday morning.
Lethbridge
-
'Good neighbours': Montana residents share thoughts on Trump's '51st state' threat
As U.S. president-elect Donald Trump threatens to annex Canada, some residents in Montana are sharing their thoughts on the idea of Canada becoming the “51st state.”
-
Man dies after falling into sink hole at Fernie Alpine Resort
An investigation is underway by Elk Valley RCMP after a man died Wednesday after falling into a sink hole at Fernie Alpine Resort.
-
One Alberta man gets jail, another community time for 2022 Coutts border protest
Two Alberta men have been sentenced for their roles in the illegal Coutts border blockade in 2022.
Winnipeg
-
'He was a genius': Family remembers man who died waiting for care in Winnipeg ER
The sister of a man who died waiting for care in the emergency department of Winnipeg’s Health Sciences Centre (HSC) is remembering her late brother as an intelligent person with a bold personality
-
High-risk offender back behind bars
A high-risk offender, who was recently released from jail, is back behind bars.
-
Contrasts start to take shape in leadership race for Manitoba's Opposition Tories
The battle for the leadership of the Manitoba Progressive Conservatives is three months from being decided, and the two men vying for the role are laying out different paths to try to reignite the party voted out of office in the last election.
Regina
-
Team Canada takes gold at U18 women's hockey worlds, Sask.'s Zablocki leads scoring
For the third time in four years, Canada has brought home gold from the Under-18 Women's World Championships – with help from Saskatchewan's own Stryker Zablocki.
-
'It gives me freedom': Local organization giving people with disabilities chance to hit the slopes
The Regina Ski Club is ensuring everyone has a chance to hit the slopes this winter.
-
Extreme cold warning issued for Regina, southeast Sask.
Much of central and southeastern Saskatchewan is now under extreme cold warnings as a cold front makes its way across the province.
Saskatoon
-
Police responding to serious crash in southern Saskatoon
A serious crash in south Saskatoon has closed the intersection of Preston Avenue South and Stonebridge Common.
-
Extreme cold blankets, Saskatoon, Prince Albert, parts of northern Sask.
An especially chilly Sunday is forecasted for several regions across Saskatchewan – as extreme cold warnings come into effect.
-
'Everybody wins': Saskatoon SPCA garage sale makes room for fundraising
Garage sale season started a little early in Saskatoon this year. The SPCA held a garage sale Saturday to make use of some its more abundant gently used donations that might go unused.
Toronto
-
Toronto police investigating pair of stabbings in Etobicoke
Police are searching for several suspects following two separate stabbings in Etobicoke on Sunday night.
-
Elderly woman pronounced deceased following two-vehicle collision in Vaughan
A woman in her 80s has died following a two-vehicle collision in Vaughan on Sunday afternoon, say police.
-
3 suspects wanted after victims robbed of their jackets at Union Station
Toronto police are looking for three suspects who allegedly approached two victims, produced an edged weapon, and robbed them of their jackets over the weekend at Union Station.
Montreal
-
Costco Canada accused of overcharging online shoppers in class-action lawsuit
Perrier Attorneys says Costco charged more for items online than in-store, a practice known as “double ticketing,” which is banned under the Competition Act.
-
CTV News Montreal at 6 p.m. for Sunday, Jan. 12, 2025
Watch CTV News Montreal at 6 p.m. for Sunday, Jan. 12, 2025 with anchor Matt Grillo.
-
Measles outbreak: Quebec Health Ministry urges caution
Due to an active measles outbreak, Quebec’s Health Ministry is urging people to be extra cautious and follow public health recommendations.
Ottawa
-
Ottawa parents voice concerns about possible phase out of some OCDSB special needs classes
Eastern Ontario's largest school board is making some major changes to how elementary students will learn in both English and French, but the new model could also mean the end of nearly 40 specialized classes, including special needs programs.
-
Ottawa police arrest suspect in Heron Gate grocery store stabbing
The Ottawa Police Service is investigating a stabbing at Herongate Square on Saturday evening.
-
'Hell on earth': Ottawa rapper TwoTiime among Canadians displaced by L.A. fires
Ottawa rapper Khalid Omar, who performs under the name TwoTiime, was forced to evacuate his Calabasas condo as wildfires tore through the Los Angeles area this week, leaving the studio where he records in ruins.
Atlantic
-
Fire Fighters Union says it is ‘heartbroken’ after fire in Lower Sackville, N.S.
A 40-year-old man was taken to hospital after his neighbour rescued him from a house fire in Lower Sackville, N.S.
-
Four teams set to represent Curl Moncton at provincial championship
Two men’s teams and two women's teams won the opportunity to represent Curl Moncton at the HUPLASO Club Curl Championships in Saint John, N.B., this February.
-
RCMP investigate suspicious death, fire in Nova Scotia's Annapolis Valley
One person is dead under suspicious circumstances after a house fire in Centreville, N.S.
London
-
'We’re bursting at the seams': BMO Centre eying $30M expansion
“We're almost at capacity here at the BMO Centre, so that's why we purchased the land,” said Operator of the BMO Centre Tom Partalas of a 10-acre parcel just west of the current facility.
-
Belmont, Ont's Lexie Bertelson bringing home gold from U18 world tournament
Lexie Bertelson of Belmont, Ont. is bringing home a gold medal after Canada beat Team USA 3-0 in the championship game of the Under-18 Women's World Championship in Vantaa, Finland.
-
41-year-old man arrested with fentanyl and cocaine on him: SPS
A 41-year-old man is facing drug trafficking charges after being sought after by police on an outstanding warrant.
Kitchener
-
WaterLAN Esport Tournament showcases inclusivity and growth in Waterloo Region: organizers
The Waterloo Region is stepping into the esports spotlight this weekend with the WaterLAN E-sports Tournament, a provincial collegiate invitational hosted by the University of Waterloo and Conestoga College.
-
Trudeau says Trump's comments on 51st state 'flattering' but a 'non-starter'
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says talk of Canada becoming the 51st state is a distraction from more pressing threats of U.S tariffs on Canada and their likely impact.
-
Costco Canada accused of overcharging online shoppers in class-action lawsuit
Perrier Attorneys says Costco charged more for items online than in-store, a practice known as “double ticketing,” which is banned under the Competition Act.
Northern Ontario
-
Two charged with first-degree murder, arson in northern Ont.
A man and a woman from Blind River have been charged with first-degree murder and a third person has been charged with accessory to murder after the fact.
-
Costco Canada accused of overcharging online shoppers in class-action lawsuit
Perrier Attorneys says Costco charged more for items online than in-store, a practice known as “double ticketing,” which is banned under the Competition Act.
-
Minister says dozens of firefighters from Alberta and B.C. to deploy in California
Emergency Preparedness Minister Harjit Sajjan says dozens of firefighters from Alberta and British Columbia will help fight wildfires in California, and the federal government is co-ordinating efforts with the provinces to deploy resources.
N.L.
-
Heavy equipment used to bash into a Newfoundland bank for second time in a month
Police in eastern Newfoundland say that for the second time in less than a month thieves have used heavy equipment to smash into a bank and steal an ATM.
-
Yvonne Jones, longtime Liberal MP for Labrador, retiring from federal politics
Liberal MP Yvonne Jones speaks to reporters before a meeting of the Liberal women's caucus, on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, on Wednesday, Jan. 24, 2024. Jones announced this morning that she will not be running in the next federal election for her seat in Labrador. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Justin Tang
-
Quebec energy deal touted as new chapter for Newfoundland and Labrador heads for vote
A draft energy deal with Quebec heralded as a game-changer for indebted Newfoundland and Labrador is heading for a vote Thursday night at the legislature in St. John's, N.L.
