B.C. business' lawsuit against client who posted negative Google review allowed to proceed
A B.C. judge has decided to let a jury decide whether a single, negative online review of a dentistry practice was defamation, dismissing a bid to have the lawsuit tossed.
In a decision posted online last week, Justice Gordon S. Funt outlined his reasons for letting the case proceed.
The civil claim was brought by Smiley Kids Dental and Dr. Edward Chin and concerns a Google review posted in 2020.
"Dr. Chin had horrible customer service and treated our child with (zero) care. Very unimpressed,” it read.
The defendants, William Huang and Sophia Nim applied to have the case dismissed under Supreme Court Civil Rule 9-5, which allows the court to dismiss all or part of a claim that has no reasonable prospect of success.
At this stage in the process, Funt explained, the issue before him was only to decide whether the statement is "capable of being defamatory” and not whether it actually was.
"If the test is met, then the applications must be dismissed. It cannot be said that the plaintiffs’ claim is bound to fail," he wrote.
Funt explained that defamation is defined in law as published words that negatively impact one's reputation or expose someone to "hatred, contempt or ridicule."
The defendants argued that the review was not defamatory because "negative reviews for almost any business are common" and the post in question was "short, vague, subjective, and did not connote an ongoing problem," according to the decision.
The test, Funt explained, requires the court to decide how a "reasonable, right-thinking person" would interpret the words. The fact that Chin was named and that the dental practice's customer service was disparaged was enough to satisfy that criterion, he ruled.
"In my view, a reasonable, right-thinking person would not view the posting as silly, vague, vacuous, or just part of the uncouthness and boorishness frequently seen on the Internet," Funt wrote, adding that the review could lead to a negative perception of the practice among prospective clients.
The decision did not provide details on what damages are being sought. While the case could still be settled out of court, Funt's decision said "the collective wisdom of a jury is particularly well-suited to make the determination."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Montreal doctors' breakthrough discovery about causes of cerebral palsy giving hope
A breakthrough discovery made by doctors at the Montreal Children's Hospital about the causes of cerebral palsy is giving new hope to one West Island family.
Weather alerts issued for 7 provinces, 1 territory
Warnings of up to 60 millimetres of rain and other alerts have been issued for seven Canadian provinces and one territory ahead of the Easter weekend.
Ontario homeowner on the hook for $27,000 when contractor severed power line
An Ontario man who built a garage on his property has been locked in a battle with his electricity provider for a year and half over a severed power line.
For years she thought her son had died of an overdose. The police video changed all that
Austin Hunter Turner died in 2017, on a night that his mother has rewound and replayed again and again, trying to make sense of what happened.
Feeling older than you are? It could be how you sleep
Not getting enough sleep may cause you to feel five to 10 years older than you really are, according to two new studies.
OPP seize $7.5 million worth of drugs in eastern Ontario
The Upper Ottawa Valley Detachment of the Ontario Provincial Police says one person is facing multiple charges after a traffic complaint on Highway 17 in Head Clara Maria Township.
CRA no longer requiring 'bare trust' reporting in 2023 tax return
The Canada Revenue Agency announced Thursday it will not require 'bare trust' reporting from Canadians that it introduced for the 2024 tax season, just four days before the April 2 deadline.
Why Kim Kardashian is being sued for 'knockoff' furniture
The estate of minimalist contemporary artist Donald Judd filed a lawsuit against Kardashian this week, claiming the fashion and beauty mogul promoted 'cheap knockoffs' of his furniture designs.
Where is the worst place for allergy sufferers in Canada?
The spring allergy season has started early in many parts of Canada, with high levels of pollen in some cities already. Experts weigh in on which areas have it worse so far this season.