Revenue from filming of U.S. TV series 'Once Upon a Time' the crux of B.C. business dispute
A recent B.C. Supreme Court case had Justice David A. Crerar invoking Rumpelstiltskin and the goose that laid the golden egg in his decision.
For six U.S. television seasons, a heritage building on Moncton Street in Richmond's Steveston village doubled as Mr. Gold's Pawn Shop – a business operated by the show's real-world version of Rumpelstiltskin – in the ABC series Once Upon a Time.
In exchange for use of the location, production company Stage 49 Ltd. made payments to both the building's owner – PD Riverside Ventures Inc. – and its two tenant businesses: The Fab Pad and It's Posh Accessories, Ltd.
The payments to the tenants stopped in 2016, however, because of a dispute between the landlord and the businesses in which Stage 49 didn't want to get involved.
That dispute ultimately led to the claim and counterclaim that Crerar decided on this week.
"When Rumpelstiltskin visited, he initially brought wealth, but eventually sowed discord," the judge writes in the opening line of his decision.
WHAT HAPPENED?
For the first two seasons of Once Upon a Time, in 2011 and 2012, the building was unoccupied outside of the filming period, according to Crerar's decision.
The landlord, which acquired the building in 2011, decided this arrangement wasn't good for the community of Steveston, the judge wrote. So, in 2013, the landlord began renting the front of the building to It's Posh owners Kimberley and Karl Sorenson and the rear of the building to Fab Pad operator Laura Elizabeth Stapleton.
Film revenues were not a part of the main lease agreement, but each tenant signed an addendum with the following three clauses, as quoted in the court documents:
- The Landlord shall retain full rights with respect to receiving compensation for the use of the exterior images of 3480 Moncton St., Richmond BC.
- The Tenant shall have the rights to receive compensation for business interruption.
- Any and all contact or negotiations for these uses shall be through the landlord only.
Despite that third clause, the tenants dealt with Stage 49 directly for their business interruption compensation, according to the decision.
"(PD Riverside co-principal Dyona) Dallas was content to allow the tenants to deal directly with Stage 49, as she was at that time focussed on her ailing parents," Crerar's decision reads.
"Testimony and emails indicate that relations between landlord and tenants during the first lease term were cordial and civil. That was soon to change. Ms. Dallas’s renewed interest, from 2015 onwards, in asserting her contractual right to be the sole contact with the production company with respect to both film payments, and the tenants’ distress with and distrust of that change led to the breakdown in relations between the parties, and to the present litigation."
CLAIM AND COUNTERCLAIM
In June 2016, Dallas contacted Stage 49 to inform them that she would be the point of contact for both types of film payments. Around this time, according to Crerar, she was also asking the tenants for information about past sales and revenue and whether they were happy with previous years' business interruption payments.
"The tenants found these inquiries surprising and troubling, given the practice of the past three years, and given the individualized nature of quantifying business interruptions," the judge wrote. "They grew anxious that Ms. Dallas would somehow try to obtain a share of the business interruption fees, directly, or via a rent increase."
The tenants sought to continue their previous arrangement with Stage 49, but the company advised that it was bound by the terms of the lease addendum. The landlord and tenants would have to resolve their issues before payments could be made directly to the businesses as they had been previously.
Crerar's decision notes that the landlord and tenants were communicating primarily through their lawyers at this point, and that no such resolution was achieved.
"In the end, the parties, through their squabbles, killed the proverbial goose that lays the golden egg," the judge wrote. "When filming recommenced on July 13, Stage 49 simply erected a façade storefront for Mr Gold’s Pawn Shop in the lane beside the premises, depriving both sides of the filming revenue streams."
Both tenants terminated their leases early and vacated the premises at the end of October 2018, according to the decision.
The landlord sued them for breaching their leases, and the tenants filed a counterclaim for the business interruption payments they never received.
DECISION
Ultimately, Crerar found the dispute to be a simple matter of contract interpretation. The lease addendum that each tenant signed was binding, and it clearly spelled out that the landlord would be the sole point of contact regarding film rights.
Though things didn't operate this way during the early years of the tenancies, Dallas always had the right to enforce the addendum, the judge wrote, though he noted that her decision to do so when she did may have been unwise.
"Both sides could have avoided this issue with more clear and timely communications and less visceral distrust and histrionics," Crerar wrote. "While the landlord was entitled to sit on its addendum rights in the (lease's) first term and assert them in the second term, it was foreseeable that its changed stance could spark the tenant reaction it did."
Crerar found in favour of the landlord in both the claim and the counterclaim, dismissing the tenants' bid for compensation and ordering them to pay the landlord base rent, common area expenses, default fees and interest for ending their tenancies early.
The judge ordered Stapleton to pay a total of $19,629.17 and the Sorensons to pay $44,396.72.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Doctors ask Liberal government to reconsider capital gains tax change
The Canadian Medical Association is asking the federal government to reconsider its proposed changes to capital gains taxation, arguing it will affect doctors' retirement savings.
Keeping these exotic pets is 'cruel' and 'dangerous,' Canadian animal advocates say
Canadian pet owners are finding companionship beyond dogs and cats. Tigers, alligators, scorpions and tarantulas are among some of the exotic pets they are keeping in private homes, which pose risks to public safety and animal welfare, advocates say.
Prince William and wife Kate thank public for birthday messages for son Louis
Prince William and his wife Kate thanked the public for their messages which had been sent to mark the sixth birthday of their youngest son Louis on Tuesday.
She was the closest she'd ever been to meeting her biological father. Then life dealt her a blow
Anne Marie Cavner was the closest she'd ever been to meeting her biological father, but then life dealt her a blow. From an unexpected loss to a host of new relationships, a DNA test changed her life, and she doesn't regret a thing.
How quietly promised law changes in the 2024 federal budget could impact your day-to-day life
The 2024 federal budget released last week includes numerous big spending promises that have garnered headlines. But, tucked into the 416-page document are also series of smaller items, such as promising to amend the law regarding infant formula and to force banks to label government rebates, that you may have missed.
Which foods have the most plastics? You may be surprised
'How much plastic will you have for dinner, sir? And you, ma'am?' While that may seem like a line from a satirical skit on Saturday Night Live, research is showing it's much too close to reality.
'Catch-and-kill' strategy to be a focus as testimony resumes in Trump hush money case
A veteran tabloid publisher was expected to return to the witness stand Tuesday in Donald Trump's historic hush money trial.
Quebec farmers have been protesting since December. Is anyone listening?
Upset about high interest rates, growing paperwork and heavy regulatory burdens, protesting farmers have become a familiar sight across Quebec since December.
South Korean sentenced to 14 months in jail for killing 76 cats
South Korean man has been sentenced to 14 months in prison for killing 76 cats in one of the country's most gruesome cases of animal cruelty in recent years.