RCMP enforcement at B.C. logging protests 'unreasonable,' federal police watchdog says
A federal police oversight agency has found the RCMP's enforcement of a civil injunction against old-growth logging protesters on Vancouver Island was unreasonable and violated the rights of activists.
The Ottawa-based Civilian Review and Complaints Commission on Wednesday published a summary of its final report into the RCMP's handling of the protests in the Fairy Creek watershed, which began in 2020.
The CRCC investigation found the protest exclusion zones and checkpoints used by members of the RCMP’s Community-Industry Response Group (C-IRG) were unreasonable, and the decisions by officers to remove their name tags and, in some cases, don "Thin Blue Line" patches broke RCMP policy.
Timber company Teal Cedar Products Ltd. won an injunction in April 2021 prohibiting protesters from obstructing its forestry operations in the watershed, approximately 120 kilometres west of Victoria.
Over the ensuing months, more than 1,100 people would be arrested in the protest exclusion zone, including many who were arrested more than once.
The C-IRG, a specialized unit that is tasked with policing protests against industry and resource-extraction infrastructure in B.C., detained at least person without cause on a public road after he refused to submit to a search, which itself was baseless, the police watchdog found.
"The review determined that the RCMP’s demand to search the complainant at a checkpoint on a public road was unfounded, and his arrest, after refusing to agree to the search, was groundless," the summary said.
Video recording of arrest
The RCMP had already conducted its own investigation into the arrest of the man – who identified himself as a hiker on a public road – and determined the search and arrest were lawful, and also concluded its officers did not have to wear name tags identifying themselves. The man then filed a complaint with CRCC, which ultimately ruled in his favour.
"The commission reviewed a video recording of the encounter and the arrest that had been made by one of the man's friends," the investigation summary said.
"The recording showed that the RCMP members told the group that they would need to provide photo identification and agree to searches of their bags before they could go any further. The man asked the RCMP members whether this was legal, and he asked them to identify themselves. The RCMP members quickly read out their regimental numbers (sometimes called "badge numbers") but they would not repeat them when asked, and they refused to tell the group their names."
When the man declined to be searched, telling the police his constitutional rights were at stake, the officers arrested him.
The commission noted that warrantless searches are only lawful following an arrest – a so-called pat-down search for weapons to ensure officer safety – or if there is reason to believe the person has committed a crime.
Police may also conduct a search without a warrant if the subject provides informed and voluntary consent to be searched, or if the delay caused by obtaining a search warrant would endanger human life or safety, or result in the disappearance of evidence, the CRCC report said.
"The commission concluded that none of those exceptions applied here," according to the summary. "There was no evidence that there was a serious risk of violence or even that weapons were being brought into the exclusion zone –instead, the RCMP was worried about letting in any construction materials that some protesters could use to create more obstacles."
Thin Blue Line patch
The report also noted that one of the arresting officers wore a "Thin Blue Line" patch on his uniform, which the investigation found is a "divisive or even hateful" symbol that "has been widely rejected as an appropriate or permitted part of police uniforms in Canada – including by the RCMP."
"The commission found that the RCMP member acted unreasonably by wearing the 'Thin Blue Line' patch on his uniform," the summary said.
"Not only did he breach RCMP policy, as the RCMP concluded, but the video evidence showed that the RCMP member took a disrespectful and even hostile tone when the man questioned the presence of the patch on the RCMP member’s uniform when it was associated with white supremacist groups."
The CRCC, which is an agency of the federal government and is independent from the police, said RCMP Commissioner Mike Duheme agreed with the commission's findings that the RCMP acted unreasonably in its enforcement of the Fairy Creek injunction.
"The RCMP commissioner also supported the recommendation that an appropriate member of the RCMP should apologize to the man for the RCMP’s failure to give proper regard to his civil liberties by arresting him without grounds," the summary said.
Critical Response Unit
The commission said it continues to review the actions of the C-IRG, which rebranded in early 2024 after years of complaints from civil rights and Indigenous groups.
The renamed Critical Response Unit (CRU-BC) was also given a new mandate in January "to better reflect the scope of work and service that its members are called to," according to a statement on the unit's website.
The CRU-BC will "continue to assist in civil and public order events for natural or human caused disasters, conduct proactive engagement and, if required, enforcement duties specific to the critical incident," the statement says.
The Fairy Creek protests began after logging permits were granted in 2020 to allow Teal Cedar to cut timber, including old-growth trees, in areas that included the Fairy Creek watershed.
Protest camps were set up close to the cutting site in August 2020 and injunctions aimed at preventing interference with logging or forestry crews followed the next year.
Confrontations escalated in 2021, leading to active RCMP intervention and what is considered one of the largest acts of civil disobedience in Canadian history.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
'No one has $70,000 dollars lying around': Toronto condo owners facing massive special assessment
The owners of a North York condominium say they are facing a $70,000 special assessment to fix their building's parking garage. '$70,000 is a lot of money. It makes me very nervous and stressed out of nowhere for this huge debt to come in,' said Ligeng Guo.
Police ID mom, daughter killed in Old Montreal; video shows person break into building before fatal fire
Police released the identities of the mother and daughter who were killed after a fire tore through a 160-year-old building in Old Montreal on Friday.
Tropical Storm Milton forms in Gulf of Mexico, could intensify as a hurricane threatening Florida
Tropical Storm Milton has formed in the Gulf of Mexico. It is located 220 miles (355 kilometres) north-northeast of Veracruz, Mexico.
'I screamed in shock and horror': Family faces deadly Vancouver hit-and-run driver during sentencing
The sentencing of the man who pleaded guilty in the deadly hit-and-run in Kitsilano two years ago began on Friday.
Inter Miami star Lionel Messi draws a crowd for arrival at Toronto's BMO Field
Argentine star Lionel Messi was on the bench to start Inter Miami CF's game in Toronto on Saturday.
Frequent drinking of fizzy beverages and fruit juice are linked to an increased risk of stroke: research
New data raises questions about the drinks people consume and the potential risks associated with them, according to researchers at Galway University in Ireland, in partnership with Hamilton’s McMaster University.
Northwestern Ont. woman charged with arson with disregard for human life
A 30-year-old northwestern Ontario woman has been charged with arson following a structure fire Thursday night, police say.
Looking for cheap flights for the holidays? Here are some tips to remember
Travelling on a budget can be stressful, but there are ways you can ensure you're getting the best deal on flights as the holiday season approaches.
A French judge in a shocking rape case allows the public to see some of the video evidence
A French judge in the trial of dozens of men accused of raping an unconscious woman whose now former husband had repeatedly drugged her so that he and others could assault her decided on Friday to allow the public to see some of the video recordings of the alleged rapes.