Murder conviction overturned, new trial ordered in Vancouver killing
British Columbia's highest court has thrown out a first-degree murder conviction and ordered a new trial in the killing of a senior on the doorstep of his East Vancouver home.
Zenen Cepeda Silva, 69, was shot dead on his porch in 2019. His wife, who was with him when the single gunshot rang out, testified that her husband's dying words identified Alvaro Julio Roche-Garcia, 58, as the shooter.
Roche-Garcia was arrested two days later and charged with the killing. A jury convicted him after a five-week trial, though clear evidence of a motive was never established. He was sentenced to 25 years in prison with no chance of parole for the murder, which the trial judge characterized as "cruel," "cold-blooded," and "cowardly."
But the B.C. Court of Appeal on Monday, more than five and a half years since the murder, overturned Roche-Garcia's conviction, finding the trial judge erred by allowing the jury to hear preliminary testimony about the shooting victim's alleged dying words without first conducting an inquiry into the admissibility and reliability of the evidence.
"I consider the consequences of this error in law to be serious," Justice Gregory Fitch wrote on behalf of the three-judge Appeal Court panel. "Identity was the main issue at trial. As is evident from their questions, the jury was focused on this very issue."
The statement identifying Roche-Garcia as the shooter wasn't the only error the appellate court found when it ordered a re-trial.
The lower court judge failed to properly instruct the jury that they must acquit the accused if they either believed his denial of guilt or if the denial raised reasonable doubt about whether he was the shooter, the Appeal Court found.
Additionally, the trial judge erred in allowing the prosecution to elicit a "highly prejudicial" statement from the victim's granddaughter, which identified Roche-Garcia as the shooter, while on the witness stand, the court ruled.
'I've been shot'
Police responded to a 911 call about a shooting on Fraser Street near East 51st Avenue at 11:47 p.m. on Jan. 26, 2019.
Cepeda Silva and his wife, Maria Baldivia, had been sitting on the front step of their home while their granddaughter, Kadesha Fuste, watched a movie inside.
Fuste testified that she heard a gunshot and then ran outside to find her grandmother screaming for help as her mortally wounded grandfather repeatedly said, "Look how this son of a b**** just killed me" and "Call the police, I've been shot."
Cepeda Silva had been shot once from behind, the bullet entering his upper right buttock and exiting his left front groin area, severing a critical artery in his pelvis and causing fatal blood loss.
During a police interview, Fuste told investigators "my whole family knows who did it," referring to the shooting. "It's fairly obvious" the shooter was Roche-Garcia, she said, according to the court transcript.
On the witness stand, Fuste testified that she did not hear her grandfather identify the shooter by name.
Speaking through a Spanish language translator, Baldivia testified she was having a cigarette with her husband on their porch and had just stood up and turned to go inside when she heard a loud bang from behind.
Cepeda Silva fell into the door and Baldivia turned to see a man holding a handgun in his outstretched arm behind a low wall on the side of the property, she said. No words were exchanged before the shooting and the couple had not spoken to anyone while outside that evening, she said.
Baldivia testified she recognized the shooter as Roche-Garcia, a man the couple had met "a long time ago" when they were living in New Mexico. She said that as she held her dying husband, he said, "Look how Alvaro has killed me."
Her testimony was given during a preliminary inquiry, rather than before the jury, because she suffered a stroke before trial and was unable to take the witness stand. In his appeal, Roche-Garcia argued that this evidence was not properly tested or challenged in court, but was "whisked into evidence" in the preliminary hearing without jury instructions from the judge.
Video of suspect vehicle
Police obtained surveillance video from the back of a restaurant near the family home on the night of the shooting. The video showed a man parking a black Hyundai and exiting the vehicle wearing a beige jacket and baseball cap, walking with an "irregular or laboured" gait in the direction of the home at 11:40 p.m., according to court records.
The man returned to the vehicle approximately 30 seconds before the first 911 call was made. Before driving away, he placed what appeared to be a handgun on the roof of the vehicle.
The owner of the vehicle recognized the car shown in the video as her own. She testified she had loaned it a week or two before the shooting to Roche-Garcia, who was a regular at the bar where she worked.
Weeks before the loan she had taken Roche-Garcia to the hospital with injuries to his face and knees after he complained of being assaulted. He told her someone had tried to run him over in a parking lot and he was worried they might recognize his vehicle and attack him again, she said.
They agreed to swap vehicles for his own protection. Roche-Garcia returned the Hyundai the morning after the shooting, she said.
Crown prosecutors suggested Roche-Garcia believed Cepeda Silva was responsible for the earlier attack and decided to exact his revenge.
Forensic evidence obtained
Roche-Garcia was arrested on Jan. 28, 2019. He wearing a beige or light-grey jacket with a black back and sleeves, the court heard. The arresting officers testified the suspect walked with a limp and needed help getting in and out of the police wagon on his ride to jail.
The bullet that killed Cepeda Silva was found lodged in the front door of the home. Forensic investigators matched it to a bullet found embedded in the refrigerator of Roche-Garcia's apartment.
Roche-Garcia did not testify at trial and called no evidence in his own defence.
Writing on behalf of the Appeal Court, Justice Fitch acknowledged the case against Roche-Garcia was "a formidable one even without Cepeda Silva's declaration identifying (him) as the shooter." However, the errors made at trial were too serious to disregard.
"There are problems with the eyewitness identification evidence, there was no clear evidence of motive, and the jury, or at least some of its members, wrestled with the central issue in the case – whether the appellant was shown beyond a reasonable doubt to have been the shooter," Fitch wrote.
"Further, first-degree murder is the most serious offence known to law and, on conviction, carries with it a sentence of life imprisonment with no parole eligibility for 25 years. There is, in my view, a compelling individual and public interest in having this charge determined by a jury of the appellant's peers on properly admissible evidence."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
DEVELOPING Police find bag carried by gunman who killed UnitedHealthcare's CEO, say he likely fled NYC on bus
Investigators found a backpack in Central Park that was carried by the shooter, police said Friday, following a massive sweep to find it in a vast area with lakes and ponds, meadows, playgrounds and a densely wooded section called 'The Ramble.'
A police photographer recounts the harrowing day of the Polytechnique massacre
Montreal crime scene photographer Harold Rosenberg witnessed a lot of horror over his 30 years on the job, though nothing of the magnitude of what he captured with his lens at the Polytechnique on Dec. 6, 1989. He described the day of the Montreal massacre to CTV Quebec Bureau Chief Genevieve Beauchemin.
Quebec premier wants to ban praying in public
Premier François Legault took advantage of the last day of the parliamentary session on Friday to announce to 'Islamists' that he will 'fight' for Quebec values and possibly use the notwithstanding clause to ban prayer in public places such as parks.
Northern Ontario man sentenced for killing his dog
WARNING: This article contains graphic details of animal abuse which may be upsetting to some readers. A 40-year-old northern Ontario man is avoiding prison after pleading guilty to killing his dog earlier this year.
'Home Alone' house up for sale for US$3.8 million in Chicago suburb – but not the one you're thinking of
Social media sleuths noticed that the house next door to the iconic 'Home Alone' house in Winnetka is now up for sale.
Purolator, UPS pause shipments from couriers amid Canada Post strike
Purolator and UPS have paused shipments from some courier companies as they try to work through a deluge of deliveries brought on by the Canada Post strike.
NDP's Singh forces debate on $250 cheques for more Canadians; Conservatives cut it short
With the fate of the federal government's promised $250 cheques for 18.7 million workers hanging in the balance, the NDP forced a debate Friday on a motion pushing for the prime minister to expand eligibility. The conversation was cut short, though, by Conservative MPs' interventions.
Sask. father who kept daughter from mom to prevent COVID-19 vaccine free from additional prison time
Michael Gordon Jackson, the Saskatchewan father who withheld his then seven-year-old daughter from her mom for nearly 100 days to prevent the girl from getting a COVID-19 vaccine, was handed a 12-month prison sentence and 200 days probation on Friday, but credited with time served.
South Korea president apologizes for declaring martial law, but did not resign. Now he faces an impeachment vote
South Korean lawmakers are set to vote later Saturday on impeaching President Yoon Suk Yeol over his short-lived attempt to impose martial law, as protests grew nationwide calling for his removal.