Marijuana company's email mistake allows shareholder to forward fraud allegations
A judge has refused to grant a B.C. cannabis company an injunction against a man who used a list of email addresses the company accidentally sent to all shareholders against it.
The man in question is Krishansarup Kallu, who owns shares of Emerald Health Sciences Inc.
In June 2018, a legal assistant for the company's corporate counsel sent an email to all shareholders, including Kallu, that failed to use the "blind carbon copy" function, making every shareholder's email address visible to every other shareholder.
Approximately two hours later, a lawyer for the company sent a follow-up email apologizing for the error, describing the email addresses as "confidential information," and asking recipients to delete the original email.
Kallu did not delete the email, according to a B.C. Supreme Court decision by Justice Ronald A. Skolrood issued in late April and posted online Wednesday.
Instead, Kallu saved the email, and eventually used it to contact every other shareholder on the list in September 2021.
"According to Mr. Kallu, he had learned that on Aug. 5, 2021, the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (the 'SEC') had filed an action in Massachusetts against, amongst others, the then-CEO of EHS, Mr. (Avtar) Dhillon, alleging financial fraud," summarizes Skolrood in his decision.
"Other named defendants in the U.S. action included some shareholders of EHS," the decision continues. "Mr. Kallu says that this raised concerns for him about the management of EHS. He says he raised these concerns in emails sent to the CFO and the Board of EHS, but got no reply. He therefore sent his Sept. 22, 2021 email to the shareholders."
The company sued Kallu, seeking an injunction to prevent him from using the names and email addresses again, and alleging that Kallu's use of the email distribution list had caused harm to the company.
Kolrood rejected the company's petition for an injunction, saying that it had failed to establish that the email addresses were, indeed, confidential, and that it had failed to establish that Kallu had misused the allegedly confidential information in his possession.
The company argued that Kallu's motivation for sending the emails was to increase the value of his own shares, which were the subject of a separate lawsuit brought by Kallu in 2020 against the company and a number of its officers and shareholders.
In that suit, Kallu argued that "he was entitled to a certain number of shares in the company for his contributions and that the company was obligated to purchase those shares from him," according to Skolrood's decision.
That lawsuit remains before the court.
While the company argued that Kallu's email was an attempt to increase the value of those shares, Skolrood found no evidence of this beyond the company's assertion that it was so.
"Mr. Kallu’s email of September 22, 2021, which gave rise to EHS’ concerns about his use of the email distribution list, says nothing about his shares," the judge writes.
"Rather, it identifies a concern about the company CEO in light of the U.S. proceedings and it encourages other shareholders to request financial information from the company. In my view, it cannot be said that raising concerns about the management and financial status of the company with other shareholders is a misuse of the information."
Finally, Skolrood added, the company failed to establish that it would suffer "demonstrable harm" without an injunction preventing Kallu from using the email list again in the future.
"With respect, these are simply bald and speculative allegations of harm not grounded in the evidence," Skolrood writes. "Moreover, the harm alleged results from the statements made by Mr. Kallu in his communications, not from the fact that he used the email distribution list to communicate with other shareholders."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Several flight attendants from Pakistan have gone missing after landing in Canada
Multiple flight attendants from Pakistan International Airlines have abandoned their jobs and are believed to have sought asylum in Canada in the past year and a half, a spokesperson for the government-owned airline says.
BREAKING Ottawa public school board, 3 Toronto-area school boards launch lawsuit against social media giants
The Ottawa-Carleton District School Board and three school boards in the Toronto-area have launched legal action against social media giants, accusing them of "disrupting students' fundamental right to education."
Rainfall warnings of up to 90 mm among weather alerts in effect for 7 provinces
Rainfall warnings of up to 90 millimetres, air quality advisories and other alerts have been issued for seven Canadian provinces, according to the latest forecasts.
Tipping is off the table at this Toronto restaurant
A Toronto restaurant introduced a surprising new rule that reduced the cost of a meal and raised the salaries of staff.
A Nigerian woman reviewed some tomato puree online. Now she faces jail
A Nigerian woman who wrote an online review of a can of tomato puree is facing imprisonment after its manufacturer accused her of making a “malicious allegation” that damaged its business.
Donald Trump assails judge and his daughter after gag order in N.Y. hush-money criminal case
Donald Trump lashed out Wednesday at the New York judge who put him under a gag order that bars him from commenting publicly about witnesses, prosecutors, court staff and jurors in his upcoming hush-money criminal trial.
A fight to protect the dignity of Michelangelo's David raises questions about freedom of expression
Michelangelo's David has been a towering figure in Italian culture since its completion in 1504. But in the current era of the quick buck, curators worry the marble statue's religious and political significance is being diminished.
Doctors visiting a Gaza hospital are stunned by the war's toll on Palestinian children
An international team of doctors visiting a hospital in central Gaza was prepared for the worst. But the gruesome impact Israel’s war against Hamas is having on Palestinian children still left them stunned.
China's latest EV is a 'connected' car from smart phone and electronics maker Xiaomi
Xiaomi, a well-known maker of smart consumer electronics in China, is joining the country's booming but crowded market for electric cars.