Marijuana company's email mistake allows shareholder to forward fraud allegations
A judge has refused to grant a B.C. cannabis company an injunction against a man who used a list of email addresses the company accidentally sent to all shareholders against it.
The man in question is Krishansarup Kallu, who owns shares of Emerald Health Sciences Inc.
In June 2018, a legal assistant for the company's corporate counsel sent an email to all shareholders, including Kallu, that failed to use the "blind carbon copy" function, making every shareholder's email address visible to every other shareholder.
Approximately two hours later, a lawyer for the company sent a follow-up email apologizing for the error, describing the email addresses as "confidential information," and asking recipients to delete the original email.
Kallu did not delete the email, according to a B.C. Supreme Court decision by Justice Ronald A. Skolrood issued in late April and posted online Wednesday.
Instead, Kallu saved the email, and eventually used it to contact every other shareholder on the list in September 2021.
"According to Mr. Kallu, he had learned that on Aug. 5, 2021, the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (the 'SEC') had filed an action in Massachusetts against, amongst others, the then-CEO of EHS, Mr. (Avtar) Dhillon, alleging financial fraud," summarizes Skolrood in his decision.
"Other named defendants in the U.S. action included some shareholders of EHS," the decision continues. "Mr. Kallu says that this raised concerns for him about the management of EHS. He says he raised these concerns in emails sent to the CFO and the Board of EHS, but got no reply. He therefore sent his Sept. 22, 2021 email to the shareholders."
The company sued Kallu, seeking an injunction to prevent him from using the names and email addresses again, and alleging that Kallu's use of the email distribution list had caused harm to the company.
Kolrood rejected the company's petition for an injunction, saying that it had failed to establish that the email addresses were, indeed, confidential, and that it had failed to establish that Kallu had misused the allegedly confidential information in his possession.
The company argued that Kallu's motivation for sending the emails was to increase the value of his own shares, which were the subject of a separate lawsuit brought by Kallu in 2020 against the company and a number of its officers and shareholders.
In that suit, Kallu argued that "he was entitled to a certain number of shares in the company for his contributions and that the company was obligated to purchase those shares from him," according to Skolrood's decision.
That lawsuit remains before the court.
While the company argued that Kallu's email was an attempt to increase the value of those shares, Skolrood found no evidence of this beyond the company's assertion that it was so.
"Mr. Kallu’s email of September 22, 2021, which gave rise to EHS’ concerns about his use of the email distribution list, says nothing about his shares," the judge writes.
"Rather, it identifies a concern about the company CEO in light of the U.S. proceedings and it encourages other shareholders to request financial information from the company. In my view, it cannot be said that raising concerns about the management and financial status of the company with other shareholders is a misuse of the information."
Finally, Skolrood added, the company failed to establish that it would suffer "demonstrable harm" without an injunction preventing Kallu from using the email list again in the future.
"With respect, these are simply bald and speculative allegations of harm not grounded in the evidence," Skolrood writes. "Moreover, the harm alleged results from the statements made by Mr. Kallu in his communications, not from the fact that he used the email distribution list to communicate with other shareholders."
Vancouver Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Patrick Brown is alleging political corruption played a role in his disqualification from the Conservative Party of Canada's leadership race, a move that came following allegations that his campaign violated election financing rules.
Despite being disqualified by the Conservative Party of Canada from becoming its next leader, ousted candidate Patrick Brown's name will still appear on the ballot.
Video has emerged showing a worker dangling in the air above a Toronto construction site after accidently getting entangled in a tagline attached to a crane.
The federal government has no intention of dropping the controversial ArriveCan app because it gives the Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) key health information about travellers who test positive for COVID-19 through testing at airports and land borders, senior government sources tell CTV News.
Air Canada and Toronto's Pearson airport again claimed the top spots for flight delays on Tuesday, marking at least four days in a row where the country's biggest airline has placed No. 1 of any large carrier worldwide.
Air Canada said on Wednesday it will not allow animals in the baggage hold until Sept. 12 due to 'longer than usual' delays at airports, as carriers and airports wrestle with complaints over lost luggage and long lines.
As gas prices slightly trend down this week after some of the highest national averages seen in recent months, some Canadians may be thinking twice before planning their usual summer road trip plans. CTVNews.ca looks at how drivers can save at the pumps while travelling.
Prices have been easing slightly recently, but affording a mortgage is still a very difficult task for many Canadians. How much of a mortgage can you afford? Contributor Christopher Liew breaks it down in an exclusive column for CTVNews.ca.
A federal judge Wednesday sentenced Jerry Harris, a former star of the Netflix documentary series 'Cheer,' to 12 years in prison for coercing teenage boys to send him obscene photos and videos of themselves and soliciting sex from minors at cheerleading competitions.
Investigators say a man was lying in the roadway when he was struck and killed by a vehicle near Courtenay, B.C., on Wednesday.
The driver of a logging truck was airlifted to hospital in Victoria after he was pinned inside the vehicle following a rollover crash on Wednesday morning.
The number of Vancouver Island marmots in the wild increased this week, with 10 of the critically endangered rodents released onto a Mount Washington ski run.
Calgary drivers might be asking why the price of gasoline is more expensive in their energy rich province where oil is refined and extracted than in Ontario, but one retail expert claims to have the answer.
Police are investigating after receiving reports of shots fired late Wednesday afternoon in Bankview.
Blackfalds RCMP were called to the scene of a serious hit and run collision Wednesday evening.
Wade Stene, who admitted to kidnapping and sexually assaulting an eight-year-old Edmonton girl, was sentenced to 15.5 years behind bars Wednesday afternoon.
Emergency crews were called to a Mill Woods school on Wednesday after a security guard reportedly experienced irritation on their hands after finding a white powder.
Blackfalds RCMP were called to the scene of a serious hit and run collision Wednesday evening.
'I cannot get any rest': Residents complain of sleepless nights after alleged nightclub opens up under condo
Residents living in Toronto’s west end say they have been left utterly exhausted after an alleged nightclub opened up at the base of their condominium.
Ontario has likely entered a new wave of the pandemic driven by the more infectious BA.5 subvariant, the province’s science advisory table says.
A mother from Nova Scotia is speaking out about her recent travel experience through Toronto Pearson Airport after a WestJet flight delay left her and her daughters sleeping on a nursing room floor.
WATCH LIVE @ 9 A.M.
WATCH LIVE @ 9 A.M. | With another COVID climb, Quebec health minister calls news conference for Thursday morning
With COVID-19 cases and hospitalizations on the rise in Quebec, public health officials have called a news conference for Thursday morning.
'Not a time when Quebec can afford to lose young doctors,' province's opposition leader says of ER exodus
The leader of Quebec's Liberal Party paused her vacation briefly on Wednesday to react to the news that two young emergency room doctors have quit their jobs in their hometown of Montreal to work in Toronto.
A prominent Montreal drag queen who recently faced pressure from critics over library readings to young children says her storytime events scheduled for the fall were abruptly called off for unknown reasons.
A political breakup at Winnipeg City Hall is creating intrigue in a council race.
A community organization is proposing a network of cameras in an effort to bolster safety throughout the area.
Residents in a southern Manitoba town are asking questions as to why they are facing a summer with no emergency room.
A crash involving a fire hydrant was the first in a chain of events that led to a chaotic scene in a Saskatoon intersection.
Starting Thursday, riders looking to take Access Transit to get to their destinations will notice a shift in service over the next three weeks.
Two Ukrainian refugees, a brother and sister, are settling into their new home in Saskatoon.
The city’s executive committee discussed possible upgrades for Regina’s recreation facilities and event venues during a meeting Wednesday.
'I feel like I have everything to lose': Riders' Tevin Jones looks to maintain place on active roster
Wide Receiver Tevin Jones got his first regular season Canadian Football League (CFL) start in week four and will look to continue the momentum against Ottawa.
SaskEnergy has gained ownership of its Regina head office building following a decade long legal battle.
A person has been taken to hospital with serious injuries following a shooting in Halifax Wednesday night.
Halifax Regional Police and fire crews are investigating after receiving reports of a missing swimmer in Dartmouth.
The ex-boyfriend of Cassidy Bernard has been sentenced to 15 years in prison for manslaughter and a consecutive three years for child abandonment in connection with the young mother's death.
Once again due to staff shortages, the emergency departments at both Listowel and Wingham hospitals will be closed overal several upcoming dates.
Provincial police have identified the victim of a deadly motorcycle collision that occurred earlier this week.
The victim of a fatal head on collision earlier this week in Blandford-Blenheim has been identified as a 41-year-old man from Plattsville.
Christ the King Church in Sudbury is looking for your scrap vehicle.
Whether you’re looking for a change of pace, a breath of fresh air, or a glimpse into nature, northern Ontario has an outdoor oasis waiting to be discovered.
The chair of the Station Mall Merchants Association says news of the mall's sale to a southern Ontario holding company brings to a close years of uncertainty regarding the future of the property.
Break-ins targeting restaurants, salons, dress shops and cannabis stores have been reported in Kitchener, Waterloo and Woolwich.
'There’s no great answer': Low-income tenants weigh options in Cambridge as renovations push them out
Tenants of the Tiger Lofts, an affordable apartment building in Cambridge, say they’re being “renovicted” and won’t be allowed to stay after extensive renovations.
Police are looking for a man who allegedly grabbed and sexually assaulted a woman in a Kitchener park.