Man who never received the 138 bottles of wine he paid $85K for in 'off the books' sale has B.C. court case dismissed
Man who never received the 138 bottles of wine he paid $85K for in 'off the books' sale has B.C. court case dismissed
A man who paid $85,000 for 138 bottles of wine more than a year and a half ago says he never received them, and he has lost his most recent bid to get his money back through the courts.
A judgment posted online Tuesday describes what the B.C. Supreme Court heard about the case earlier this month.
In November of 2020, Moez Kassam, described as a "business person and wine collector" who lives in Ontario, ordered the bottles of burgundy from a man named Brian Gunsten, who lives in Alberta.
HOW DID THE CASE END UP IN A B.C. COURT?
The case came before B.C. judge Andrew Mayer because Kassam was trying to sue a company called Dream Wines Corporation, an Alberta company that has its head office in North Vancouver. At the time of the transaction, Gunsten worked for that company.
Gunsten was also named in the suit but never filed a response and did not attend the hearing, and the court was advised that he is "now bankrupt," Mayer said.
Kassam argued, court documents show, that Dream Wines should be held "vicariously liable" for the actions of its employee and ordered to pay him $85,000 plus interest and court costs.
It was an argument the judge roundly rejected, siding with the company and granting its application to dismiss the claim.
THE COMPANY'S ARGUMENT
The company argued that not only did it have no involvement in the contract between Kassam and Gunsten, but that the deal itself was so "tainted with illegality" that enforcing it would be against "public policy," the judge summarized. To support that claim the company pointed out that there was no GST or PST on the invoice, and that the wine would have been shipped between provinces in defiance of Ontario's liquor control legislation.
The company also told the court that Gunsten was fired in 2021 because he was "moonlighting" by making these kinds of side sales.
Kassam's attempts to get reimbursed by Gunsten directly continued in a series of text messages that happened after Gunsten was fired, something Kassam admitted he was aware of. Two payments – of $1,500 and $200 respectively – were also accepted by Kassam as partial reimbursement.
"Mr. Kassam did not reach out to the president of Dream Wines, Eric Tetrault, until May 12, 2021 – approximately five months after his company forwarded $85,000 to Mr. Gunsten," the court decision says.
Kassam told the court that Gunsten communicated with him using his work email address, arguing that implicated the company in the deal. Further, he said "subjectively believed that he was entering into a contract with Dream Wines," the court heard.
'OFF THE BOOKS' SALE
The judge also looked at a prior deal made between Kassam and Gunsten in which 18 bottles of wine were sold for $50,000. That sale was completed and the court noted the payment was wired to Gunsten's personal bank account.
The invoice in that case was issued by Gunsten and -- like the transaction being considered by the court -- did not include federal or provincial sales tax, which the judge found indicated it was "off the books."
Additional evidence presented by the company showed that they do not sell wine directly to individuals and that none of the bottles Kassam purchased or tried to purchase were ever listed for sale on their website.
WHAT HAPPENED TO THE WINE?
Kassam also alleged that Gunsten, and by extension the company, engaged in "conversion."
"(This) occurs when a person without authority or permission wrongfully interferes with the goods of another, such as by taking their goods," the judge explained.
"Having the funds of another person, without that person’s permission, and without such possession being pursuant to any legal entitlement amounts to conversion."
However, since Kassam entered the contract willingly and because there was no evidence Gunsten used the money for his own gain or withheld the wine, the judge dismissed this claim.
"The documentary evidence suggests that Mr. Gunsten paid for the wine using the $85,000 provided by Anson Advisors Inc. but the wine shipment was damaged and sent back. The evidence also suggests that Mr. Gunsten was seeking to obtain a return of the $85,000 which would be reimbursed. This never occurred," the decision reads.
Privacy and civil liberties experts are sharing their concerns Tuesday with MPs studying the RCMP's yearslong use of spyware in major investigations, calling the previously undisclosed tools 'extremely intrusive' and criticizing the RCMP's belated disclosure of its use of these tools.
Ontario Premier Doug Ford says through his throne speech that more can be done to ease health system pressures, but is not yet offering up any new solutions.
Former U.S. President Donald Trump on Tuesday tried to turn the news of an FBI search of his Florida estate to his benefit, citing the investigation in text messages and emails soliciting political donations from his supporters.
The detention and alleged beating by Quebec police of a Senegalese diplomat last week came as a bailiff was attempting to seize property at her residence to pay for a judgment against her.
The serious shortage of nurses and doctors has put the spotlight on a long overdue reform to the rules governing entrance requirements for foreign-trained professionals, says former NDP leader Tom Mulcair in an exclusive column for CTVNews.ca.
For the first time in eight years, Canadian warships are not involved in either of two NATO naval task forces charged with patrolling European waters and defending against Russian threats.
The search is still on for a missing Port Alberni woman, and friends and family are hoping that a new podcast revolving around the 40-year-old's disappearance will help keep the investigation in people's minds.
Calgary police are warning citizens about an extortion scam that sees victims sent graphic and violent photos to intimidate them into handing over their hard-earned money.
A prominent American ballerina and her husband have withdrawn a claim that Edmonton Oilers owner Daryl Katz paid for sex with an underage dancer several years ago, saying they have since learned she was 18 at the time.
Ontario Premier Doug Ford says through his throne speech that more can be done to ease health system pressures, but is not yet offering up any new solutions.
Francois Legault has reiterated his confidence in his MNA and candidate in Cote-du-Sud, Marie-Eve Proulx, despite a new psychological harassment complaint filed against her.
Manitoba’s police watchdog has concluded its investigation into an officer-involved shooting in Thompson last year, and determined that the officer’s decision to shoot the man was “reasonable, necessary and justified in law.”
Privacy and civil liberties experts are sharing their concerns Tuesday with MPs studying the RCMP's yearslong use of spyware in major investigations, calling the previously undisclosed tools 'extremely intrusive' and criticizing the RCMP's belated disclosure of its use of these tools.
The Government of Canada has negotiated a settlement with Beardy’s and Okemasis’ Cree Nation for lost salaries and annuities promised to chiefs and headmen under Treaty 6.
The search for a man who went missing while swimming near Pelican Pointe on Last Mountain Lake, Sask. will continue on Tuesday, according to a release from Southey RCMP.
The reopening of a Newfoundland highway that had been closed for days because of raging wildfires provided hope Tuesday that much-needed supplies would finally arrive in stranded communities along the island's south coast.
As the doctor wait list hits 74,000 in New Brunswick, one woman is turning to social media with her pitch to try to find a replacement after losing her own doctor.
A number of people are living in tents in a small park just off Sackville Drive in Lower Sackville, N.S., as they struggle to cope with inflation and find affordable housing.
An 84-year-old Timmins man is facing a list of firearms-related charges following an incident at an undeveloped lot involved in an ongoing dispute with city bylaw officials, police said.
Ontario Premier Doug Ford says through his throne speech that more can be done to ease health system pressures, but is not yet offering up any new solutions.
An ambitious plan aimed at ending homelessness in Waterloo region went before regional council on Tuesday, giving members the chance to hear the latest plans for interim housing solutions.
