Left with reasonable doubt, B.C. judge finds man not guilty of sexually assaulting his ex-girlfriend's 8-year-old daughter
A B.C. man has been found not guilty of sexually assaulting his ex-girlfriend’s daughter nearly a decade ago, when the girl would have been just eight years old.
The reasons are outlined in a recent B.C. Supreme Court decision, which refers to the parties only by their initials to protect the teenage complainant’s privacy.
The daughter, C.M., accused her mother’s ex-boyfriend, C.J.H., of sexually assaulting her on two occasions–something he fully denies.
“I am unable to determine who to believe and am therefore compelled to find that that there is a reasonable doubt,” Justice Jacqueline Hughes wrote in her ruling earlier this month, pointing to inconsistencies in C.M.’s evidence.
The complainant’s mother, E.H., was in a romantic relationship with the accused for nearly a decade until 2014, and had a biological child with him, referred to as O.H.
C.M. testified that C.J.H. “acted in a stepfather role” towards her during that time, the decision reads. But in 2012 or 2013, around Christmas, she alleges C.J.H. sexually assaulted her at E.H.’s home in Aldergrove.
C.M. didn’t report it to police until December 2020, when she was 16 years old.
At 18 years old, C.M. testified in court last month that C.J.H “moved her hand up and down his penis” during one incident. She says he also “licked her vagina” on another occasion around the same time.
The judge noted there were some discrepancies between C.M’s testimony and what she initially told police. She previously alleged that C.J.H. made her give him oral sex, and that both incidents may have occurred on the same day.
In addition, Hughes highlighted that while C.M. could not explain to police how C.J.H made her touch him, she testified at trial that he would call her into the bedroom to play a made-up “bum squeezes” game.
At trial, the Crown argued these inconsistencies were due to the lapse in time and a child’s ability to remember childhood events.
C.M. said the differences between her accounts were due to the fact that her memory improved after years of therapy, according to the decision.
Hughes, however, found that the inconsistencies between accounts of only two incidents were “not merely peripheral or attributable to her young age at the relevant time.”
C.J.H., who is 44 years old, denies ever sexually touching C.M., and testified that he considered “to be like his own daughter.”
The accused suggested in court that the complaints were related to a custody battle over O.H., which has been an issue between E.H. and C.J.H. since 2019.
According to the decision, C.J.H. wants 50 per cent custody of his son, and has not been allowed him to see since last October.
“C.J.H. also notes C.M. was aware of the custody dispute at the time the allegations were made, wanted O.H. to stay with her and E.H., wanted to help E.H. however she could, knew that if convicted C.J.H. would go to jail, and if that happened, E.H. would get custody of O.H.,” Hughes wrote in her decision.
Hughes wrote in her decision that she can’t conclude those factors led C.M. to fabricate allegations against C.J.H., but she also can’t conclude they didn’t.
“This is not to say that I do not believe C.M.; rather, given the inconsistencies in her evidence, I am not confident that I can accept the Crown’s version of events,” the judge wrote.
As a result, Hughes found C.J.H not guilty on both counts.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Poilievre will do 'anything to win,' must condemn Alex Jones endorsement: Trudeau
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is ramping up his attacks on Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre as he promotes his government's federal budget.
'My stomach dropped': Winnipeg man speaks out after being criminally harassed following single online date
A Winnipeg man said a single date gone wrong led to years of criminal harassment, false arrests, stress and depression.
New evidence challenges the Pentagon's account of a horrific attack as the U.S. withdrew from Afghanistan: CNN exclusive
New video evidence uncovered by CNN significantly undermines two Pentagon investigations into an ISIS-K suicide attack outside Kabul airport, during the American withdrawal from Afghanistan in 2021.
'One of the single most terrifying things ever': Ontario couple among passengers on sinking tour boat in Dominican Republic
A Toronto couple are speaking out about their 'extremely dangerous' experience on board a sinking tour boat in the Dominican Republic last week.
All Alberta wildfires to date in 2024 believed to be human-caused: province
There are 63 wildfires burning in Alberta's forest protection area as of Wednesday morning and seven mutual aid fires, including one in the Municipal District of Peace.
Video shows suspects waving weapons, smashing glass in Toronto jewelry store robbery
Arrests have been made after five men were captured on video rampaging through a jewelry store in Toronto, waving weapons and smashing glass display cases.
Pilot proposes to flight attendant girlfriend in front of passengers
A Polish pilot proposed to his flight attendant girlfriend during a flight from Warsaw to Krakow, and she said yes.
Ottawa injects another $36M into fund for those seriously injured or killed by vaccines
The federal government has added $36.4 million to a program designed to support people who have been seriously injured or killed by vaccines since the end of 2020.
Ex-SNC executive sentenced to prison term in bridge bribery case
The RCMP says a former SNC-Lavalin executive has been sentenced to three and a half years in prison in connection with a bribery scheme for a bridge repair contract in Montreal.