Kelowna man did not cause poodle to become dangerous: judge
Kelowna man did not cause poodle to become dangerous: judge
Kelowna man did not cause poodle to become dangerous: judge
This photo from Shutterstock shows a poodle lying in the grass. It is not an image of the poodle from this story.
A Kelowna man has successfully appealed a $1,000 fine he was issued for "causing or permitting" his poodle to become a dangerous dog,
A B.C. Supreme Court decision, posted Friday, outlines what led up to the fine and why it was ultimately set aside.
The ticket dates back to January of 2020 when Ian Sisett had his three dogs – large poodles named Charlie, Diva, and Biscuit – off-leash at Okanagan College.
A woman passing by, the court heard, was walking her "small dog" named Spike when Sisett's dogs approached. The court was told the woman was able to chase off two of them, but not the third.
"Charlie grabbed Spike by the head and shook him, causing significant injuries including a fractured jaw that needed to be wired shut until it healed," the court decision says, noting the ensuing vet bill amounted to more than $6,000.
Justice Gary P. Weatherill found that because Charlie injured Spike and because Spike's injuries were serious, the determination that the poodle was dangerous was not wrong.
But the fact that Charlie was off-leash in an area where that was not allowed was not enough evidence to prove that Sisett had violated the bylaw, the judge found.
"Before one can 'cause or permit' a dog to become a dangerous dog, there must be a degree of active participation or control in encouraging a dog to be dangerous … or a state of indifference or acquiescence in knowing a dog has a propensity towards violence and doing nothing about it," the judgment says.
"There was no evidence … that remotely suggested Mr. Sisett knew that Charlie had any such propensity. Indeed, the evidence is to the contrary, that Charlie was a one-year-old playful puppy that liked to 'sniff' other dogs in the same manner most dogs greet each other. There is no evidence that the incident was anything other than a one-off event."
Sisett also appealed the conviction on the grounds that the judge and prosecutor were biased against him, that he was denied the opportunity to properly prepare, and that he was prevented from cross-examining witnesses.
"I find no merit to Mr. Sisett’s submissions regarding the fairness of the trial," the judge wrote.
An Ontario community is reeling after a 23-month-old boy died when he was accidentally left in a hot car outside the school where his mother taught, the mayor says.
Group of Seven leaders considered a possible cap on the price of Russian gas exports on Monday as a way to put the squeeze on the funding for Vladimir Putin's war with Ukraine.
Russian long-range bombers fired a missile that struck a crowded shopping mall in Ukraine's central city of Kremenchuk on Monday, raising fears of what President Volodymyr Zelenskyy called an 'unimaginable' number of victims in 'one of the most disastrous terrorist attacks in European history.'
A passenger train traveling from Los Angeles to Chicago struck a dump truck and derailed Monday in a remote, rural area of Missouri, killing three people and injuring dozens more, officials said.
Organizers of a central Alberta rodeo and its parade committee are calling for calm after a float in this weekend's parade, which possessed a racist theme, was seen in the procession.
Despite goals of hitting climate targets and building up instead of out, the city is considering approving five new communities as it expects another 88,000 people to move here by 2026.
An Edmonton city councillor on Monday both apologized for a social media post he shared and called an attempt to have him sanctioned for it a "smear job."
An Ontario community is reeling after a 23-month-old boy died when he was accidentally left in a hot car outside the school where his mother taught, the mayor says.
An Ontario man whose car was stolen from his driveway in midtown Toronto twice in three months is revealing how he tracked and located his second vehicle.
Nemeroff was in his early 30s and had gathered a list of accolades, including appearing on Conan and at Just For Laughs and being nominated for a Juno. Raised in Montreal West, he also leaves behind a grieving family.
Black Quebecers suffering from serious disease like sickle cell anemia need more Black blood donors, whose blood is most likely to match their own. Hema-Quebec is trying to reach these 'under-represented' potential donors.
J.W. McDonald Auto Service has had a few names over the years but it has always been able to provide vehicle service to Winnipeggers. But now, the Exchange District staple is gearing down and set to close its doors for good.
Holiday Park Golf Course turned 60 years old on Monday morning, and just like the day it first opened when Mayor Sid Buckwold took the first swing, Mayor Charlie Clark was on hand to tee off with a couple of shots.
A seven-year-old Regina boy is being treated for serious injuries after being struck by a vehicle at a bus stop in Regina on June 21, according to an online fundraiser.
Nova Scotia is expanding eligibility for second COVID-19 booster doses to include anyone aged 50 and over, however health officials are suggesting people wait to book appointments until the fall.
After a weekend full of rallies and protests across North America, the outrage after the U.S. Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe V. Wade hasn’t died down.
The Special Investigations Unit has found that a London police officer did not commit a criminal offence in the shooting death of tennis coach Justin Bourassa last October.
Four London teenagers are facing charges Monday for their alleged involvement after a police officer was assaulted and knives and drugs were seized over the weekend, according to police.
As eviction day at a downtown Kitchener encampment looms, the region is doubling down that no one will be forcibly removed from the site on June 30 – the date it has said everyone living there must leave by.
This photo from Shutterstock shows a poodle lying in the grass. It is not an image of the poodle from this story.
