Hertz tells B.C. tribunal online reservations do not 'guarantee' an available car
A man who showed up at a rental car company only to be told his online reservation would not be honoured is entitled to compensation, B.C.'s small claims tribunal has ruled.
The dispute dates back to June of 2023 when Lorne Whaley booked a car online with Hertz Canada Limited. Whaley was seeking damages for the cost of securing another vehicle as well as "stress caused by this incident," according to a decision posted online Tuesday.
The company acknowledged that Whaley booked a car and that it did not provide one on the date and time for which it was reserved. However, Hertz argued the online reservation did not "establish a contractual relationship" and did not "guarantee an available car," according to the decision.
The company did not provide any evidence to the tribunal at all, meaning there was none submitted in support of this argument – such as a copy of the reservation or information about its policies – to support the claim that reservations were "subject to availability."
Tribunal member Peter Mennie found that a reservation "implies that Hertz set aside a car" and that the company broke its agreement to rent a car to Whaley by failing to provide one – meaning it was liable for breach of contract.
When Whaley showed up at Hertz to pick up the car, an employee directed him to another rental company. That company also did not have any vehicles but helped Whaley find an available vehicle at another location further away, the decision says.
Hertz was ordered to pay Whaley $59, the amount he spent on taxis getting to and from the place where he ultimately rented a car. The company was also ordered to pay Whaley $60 for a fee he incurred that he would not have if his initial reservation had been honoured.
"Mr. Whaley paid these extra costs as a consequence of Hertz breaching the parties’ contract," the decision said.
Damages for mental distress
Whaley told the tribunal that it took hours to rent a car, delaying his plans and causing the stress for which he sought to be compensated.
"He and two elderly family members were planning to travel that day, but the delay caused them to arrive at their destination too late to see an unwell relative," Mennie wrote.
"I infer that Mr. Whaley is claiming mental distress damages."
These types of damages, the decision said, are not generally available in breach of contract cases. One of the exceptions to this is when "part of the contract’s purpose was for a 'psychological benefit.'''
In this case, Mennie found that there was a psychological benefit to the reservation – "namely that reserving a car rental would make his travel less stressful."
Mental distress, legally, is defined as something that goes "beyond mere frustration or disappointment," the decision noted, finding that Whaley's experience met this threshold.
"I accept that a four-hour delay for three seniors travelling to visit a sick relative caused Mr. Whaley mental distress that went beyond mere frustration or disappointment," the decision said.
"I find that this was a foreseeable consequence of Hertz not having a car available."
Whaley was awarded $200 in damages as compensation.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Canada's response to Trump deportation plan a key focus of revived cabinet committee
U.S. president-elect Donald Trump's promise to launch a mass deportation of millions of undocumented people has the Canadian government looking at its own border.
Who should lead the Liberals? 'None of the above,' poll finds
As questions loom over Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s leadership, a new Nanos Research poll commissioned for CTV News says a quarter of Canadians say none of the potential candidates appeal to them.
New technology solves mystery of late First World War soldier's flower sent home to Canada
In 1916, Harold Wrong plucked a flower from the fields of Somme, France and tucked it into a letter he mailed home to Toronto. For decades, the type of flower sent remained a mystery.
U.S. election maps: How did 2024 compare to 2020 and 2016?
Though two states have yet to be officially called, the U.S. election map has mostly been settled. How does it compare with the previous two elections?
Canada rent report: What landlords are asking tenants to pay
Average asking rents declined nationally on a year-over-year basis for the first time in more than three years in October, said a report out Thursday.
N.S. school 'deeply sorry' for asking service members not to wear uniforms at Remembrance Day ceremony
An elementary school in the Halifax area has backed away from a request that service members not wear uniforms to the school's Remembrance Day ceremony.
Remembrance Day: What's open and closed in Canada?
While banks and post offices will be closed nationwide on Remembrance Day, shops and businesses could be open depending on where you live in Canada.
Judicial recount for Surrey-Guildford confirms B.C. NDP's majority
The B.C. New Democrats have a majority government of 47 seats after a judicial recount in the riding of Surrey-Guildford gave the party's candidate 22 more votes than the provincial Conservatives.
48,584 space heaters recalled in Canada after burn injury in U.S.
Health Canada has announced a recall for electric space heaters over potential fire and burn risks, a notice published Thursday reads.