Dog custody dispute between B.C. exes highlights complexity of proving ownership
A B.C. woman has been ordered to return a dog she says she received as a gift through a verbal agreement and repay hundreds of dollars for a pet deposit.
The ownership dispute, outlined in a recent B.C. Civil Resolution Tribunal decision, was between two parties who disagreed about who owned a Rottweiler named Onyxia.
The decision explained Elaine Hughes and Philip Arnold, who were in a relationship and bought Onyxia together in 2017, believed they had joint ownership of the dog. However, Lori Arscott, who was later in a relationship with Arnold until 2021, claimed Onyxia was gifted to her.
"I accept that all parties are emotionally attached to Onyxia," wrote Andrea Ritchie in her decision. "However, the law treats pets as personal property, rather than family members."
Ritchie explained both Arnold and Hughes agreed Onyxia would be shared between the two of them after the end of their relationship. But Arscott said she didn't know about this arrangement "before Onyxia was allegedly gifted" to her.
Ritchie said all three contributed to caring for Onyxia, both physically and financially, until February 2021.
"On Feb. 16, 2021, Mr. Arnold asked for Onyxia, and Ms. Arscott declined to give Onyxia to him. Ms. Hughes and Mr. Arnold have been denied access to Onyxia since this date," Ritchie wrote.
"Mr. Arnold and Ms. Hughes seek an order that Ms. Arscott return Onyxia to them, because they say they are the dog’s rightful owners."
The tribunal heard both Arnold and Arscott disagreed over whether Onyxia was ever permanently gifted to Arscott, who claimed this was arranged through a verbal agreement. However, Ritchie determined there was no evidence to prove that conversation happened.
In CRT submissions, those making a claim must prove it on a balance of probabilities.
"Although all parties contributed to Onyxia’s care over the years, I find Ms. Hughes and Mr. Arnold have a stronger ownership claim over her, as they have remained intimately involved in her care and expenses," Ritchie wrote.
"I order Ms. Arscott to return the dog to Ms. Hughes and Mr. Arnold."
Arscott was also ordered to pay nearly $1,000 for CRT fees, a pet deposit covered by Arnold and applicable interest. Ritchie ruled Arscott wasn't entitled to any expenses because "all three parties contributed to Onyxia's care."
Arscott was ordered to return Onyxia to Arnold and Hughes within 30 days.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
American millionaire Jonathan Lehrer denied bail after being charged with killing Canadian couple
American millionaire Jonathan Lehrer, one of two men charged in the killings of a Canadian couple in Dominica, has been denied bail.
LeBlanc says he plans to run in next election, under Trudeau's leadership
Cabinet minister Dominic LeBlanc says he plans to run in the next election as a candidate under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's leadership, amid questions about his rumoured interest in succeeding his longtime friend for the top job.
Grandparent scam suspects had ties to Italian organized crime, Ontario police allege
A group of suspects that allegedly defrauded seniors across Ontario and other parts of Canada using a so-called emergency grandparent scam appear to have ties to 'Italian traditional organized crime,' according to an investigator involved in the OPP-led probe.
Sports columnist apologizes for ‘oafish’ comments directed at Caitlin Clark. The controversy isn’t over
A male columnist has apologized for a cringeworthy moment during former University of Iowa superstar and college basketball’s highest scorer Caitlin Clark’s first news conference as an Indiana Fever player.
Trend Line Anger, pessimism towards federal government reach six-year high: Nanos survey
Most Canadians in March reported feeling angry or pessimistic towards the federal government than at any point in the last six years, according to a survey by Nanos Research.
BREAKING B.C.'s short-term rental regulations include $10K daily penalties for Airbnb, other platforms
Short-term rental platforms that violate B.C.'s pending regulations can face administrative penalties of up to $10,000 per day, officials announced Thursday.
Taylor Swift's new album allegedly 'leaked' on social media and it's causing a frenzy
A Google Drive link allegedly containing 17 tracks that are purportedly from Swift's eagerly awaited "The Tortured Poets Department" album has been making the rounds on the internet in the past day and people are equal parts mad, sad and happy about it.
Motion to allow keffiyehs at Ontario legislature fails
A motion to reverse a ban on the keffiyeh within Queen’s Park failed to receive unanimous consent Thursday just moments after Ontario Premier Doug Ford reiterated his view that prohibiting the garment in the House is divisive.
'Shopaholic' author Sophie Kinsella reveals brain cancer diagnosis
Sophie Kinsella, the best-selling author behind the 'Shopaholic' book series, has revealed that she is receiving treatment for brain cancer.