Defence argues 'no direct evidence' of how drugs got into child's system in final submissions at B.C. mother's murder trial
Warning: Disturbing content
VANCOUVER -- The defence lawyer for a Langley, B.C., woman accused of killing her seven-year-old daughter told the court there is a “huge lack of evidence” in the case, as part of her final submissions.
Kerry Ann Lewis is charged with first-degree murder in connection with the death of her daughter, Aaliyah Rosa. The little girl’s body was found at her mother’s apartment on July 22, 2018.
The Crown’s theory is that Lewis sedated her daughter, and then drowned her in the bathtub at her suite. None of the allegations have been proven in court.
In closing arguments on Monday, prosecutor Chris McPherson said two drugs were found in Aaliyah’s body: lorazepam, which is sold under the brand name Ativan, and diphenhydramine.
He told the court Lewis purchased an emergency single dose of Ativan that morning, as well as an over-the-counter sleeping medication in which diphenhydramine is the active ingredient. The Crown also said Lewis bought a bottle of blue Powerade at the same time.
Earlier in the trial, an officer with the Integrated Homicide Investigation Team testified a bottle of blue liquid photographed in the apartment following Aaliyah’s death was not seized by police.
In an image taken by investigators, the Crown said the bottle appears to be roughly half-full. In their closing submissions, the Crown also said video surveillance from the morning of July 22 showed Aaliyah holding what looks like a bottle of blue Powerade while out with her mother, following their visit to the Shoppers Drug Mart.
On Thursday, defence lawyer Marilyn Sandford told the court there is no direct evidence about how the drugs ended up in Aaliyah’s body.
“We have no evidence of how they got into her system,” she said.
Sandford said “there’s no inference suggesting criminality” in Lewis purchasing Ativan.
“We know that Ms. Lewis was in a crisis because of the break-up of her relationship mere hours earlier,” she told the court.
Sandford told the court when it comes to the sleeping medication, Lewis had been up in the night sending messages to her ex-boyfriend, and the drug store clerk also testified she looked “tired.”
“It shows there wasn’t much time for her to sleep,” Sandford said. “Her obtaining sleep medication…is entirely consistent with her obtaining it for personal use.”
During the trial, the defence called a pediatric neuropathologist who testified a pre-existing brain condition known as hydrocephalus combined with a blow to the head could have contributed to Aaliyah’s death.
“There’s no question this child had drugs in her system that would have had a sedative effect,” Sandford said. “That of course increases the chance of a fall or accident leading to trauma.”
She argued the Crown’s theory failed to consider other pieces of evidence, and doesn’t account for the pathology.
“There’s a whole range of possibilities here. They have selected one,” Sandford said, and called it a “hypothetical narrative.”
“There’s a huge lack of evidence in this case," Sandford said.
Sandford also said the defence is arguing there is an “absence of motive” in the case.
McPherson previously told the court for months leading up to Aaliyah’s death, Lewis had complained repeatedly to friends and family about her access to her daughter, which at the time involved two unsupervised visits a week, and also expressed resentment towards her ex-husband. The court had heard Aaliyah’s father had custody of the little girl, following his separation from Lewis in 2016.
“The evidence is quite clear, in the Crown’s submission, that (Lewis’s) state of mind had been deteriorating,” McPherson said Monday. “There was, at the very least, significant conflict in some of her closest relationships.”
During the trial, the court heard testimony that Lewis’s boyfriend had broken up with her, and she was also trying to get money back from a gifting club.
McPherson said on the morning Aaliyah died, Lewis picked her up from her father for one of their scheduled visits. He told the court Aaliyah’s father testified she was a healthy, active child who was rarely sick and never took medication on her own.
The child’s body was found later that same day in her mother’s apartment, next to the ensuite bathtub. McPherson told the court Aaliyah was wet and cold.
Sandford also pointed to witnesses who attended the apartment that night, who testified Lewis appeared to be slurring and groggy. The court heard police found an empty bottle of vodka in the unit, as well as a partially empty whisky bottle.
McPherson argued despite evidence of intoxication, “drunken intent is nevertheless intent.”
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
These symptoms could mean you damaged your eyes from watching the eclipse
If you watched Monday's solar eclipse, you may be wondering whether you damaged your eyes. CTVNews.ca spoke with eye-care experts to find out what to do if you have concerns about your eyesight after observing the rare celestial event.
Warning light on Boeing 737 prompts Air Canada flight to make emergency landing
An Air Canada Boeing 737 Max 8 landed safely in Idaho after experiencing an in-flight emergency Tuesday when pilots received a warning light in the flight deck, airline and airport officials said.
'Extremely dangerous': Toddler, 2 other children left unsupervised in parking lot for 4 hours while moms went to Pickering casino: police
Two women have been charged after leaving three young children unsupervised in a parking lot for hours while they went to a casino in Pickering on Monday, say police.
Amanda Knox faces a new slander trial in Italy that could remove the last legal stain against her
Amanda Knox faces another trial for slander this week in Italy in a case that could remove the last legal stain against her, eight years after Italy's highest court threw out her conviction for the murder of her 21-year-old British roommate.
Food critic leaves $3,000 tip at Toronto restaurant
Celebrity food critic Keith Lee dropped a $3,000 tip at a Toronto restaurant over the weekend, but it’s the 'Keith Lee Effect' that leaves a lasting impact.
Rescued hiker reunited with missing dog thanks to Vancouver Island volunteer
An injured hiker who was airlifted by search and rescue teams near Port Alberni, B.C., over the weekend has been reunited with his dog, after a dedicated rescuer went back to find her.
Missouri man executed for killing his cousin and her husband in 2006
A Missouri man was executed Tuesday for killing his cousin and her husband nearly two decades ago in an attack that left the couple's four-year-old daughter home alone and unharmed.
Here's what to do with your solar eclipse glasses, instead of throwing them out
As countless sun-gazers settle in for the long wait until their next solar eclipse, many may be asking themselves the same question. Eclipse glasses are typically mass-produced from cardboard frames and polymer filters, so some may be tempted to toss them out, but a number of organizations are hoping you'll think twice before you do.
Quebec premier threatens 'referendum' on immigration if Trudeau fails to deliver
Quebec Premier François Legault on Tuesday ratcheted up pressure on the federal government to reduce the number of temporary immigrants in the province, threatening to hold a "referendum" on the issue.