Company must refund $1-million deposit after failing to complete West Vancouver home on time, court rules
A West Vancouver company has been ordered to repay a homebuyer's $1-million deposit after it failed to complete construction on the property in time.
According to a B.C. Supreme Court decision issued last week and published online Monday, Zihao Yan – also known as Tony Yan – entered a contract with Benbow Residences Inc. in 2018 to purchase a home on Benbow Road in the district's Westmount neighbourhood for $5.38 million.
Under the agreement, the court decision indicates, Yan would take possession of the property on Nov. 15, 2018, and the closing date for the transaction would be Oct. 30, 2019.
Before the closing date, Benbow Residences was required to complete construction on the home – including addressing 43 "deficiencies" identified after an inspection – and to provide an occupancy permit.
Yan took possession as planned in November 2018, with construction ongoing, according to the decision. He spent December 2018 and January 2019 in China, expecting that he would return to find the deficiencies addressed and construction completed.
"When Mr. Yan returned from China, not only were many of the deficiencies not fixed, but the property was in a state of upheaval," reads B.C. Supreme Court Justice Sandra M. Sukstorf's decision.
"For example, the driveway was dug up and was unusable, there was no working boiler to heat the pool and hot tub, the smart controls in the home did not work, the security system did not work, and the patio doors did not close."
"A similar state of affairs continued until late October 2019," the decision notes.
Nonetheless, Yan continued to prepare to complete the purchase, according to Sukstorf's decision.
He secured a $2.7-million mortgage and liquidated investments worth another $1.86 million to combine with his $1 million deposit and account for the purchase price.
Yan also obtained property insurance and instructed his lawyers to "take the necessary steps to complete the transaction," according to the decision.
While Yan was prepared to complete his purchase, the decision indicates, Benbow Residences was not.
"The defendant’s conveyancing lawyer initially forwarded (Yan’s lawyer's) office an occupancy permit for an entirely different property," the decision reads.
"When this was brought to their attention, the defendant’s conveyancing lawyer then suggested that the correct occupancy permit must have already been provided. The evidence confirmed that the defendant had not obtained an occupancy permit on the date of closing and would not obtain one until Sept. 17, 2020, some 10 months after the completion date."
Defendant stopped responding
When the transaction was not completed as planned, Yan's lawyer sent a letter to Benbow Residences informing the company that it had breached a fundamental term of the contract, and requested the return of Yan's deposit, according to the court decision.
Benbow Residences did not return the deposit, so Yan filed his lawsuit.
Phil Garrow, the company's president and director, filed a response to the lawsuit and a counterclaim alleging that it was Yan, not Benbow Residences, that had repudiated the contract.
The decision indicates Garrow initially corresponded with Yan's lawyers and participated in the court process, but later stopped communicating and did not participate in the trial.
Sukstorf determined that the trial should continue in the defendant's absence, noting that Garrow and his company were aware of the trial date and their obligations, and had demonstrated through earlier non-compliance a failure to "engage meaningfully in the litigation."
"If the defendant later seeks to set aside the judgment, he will need to provide a compelling explanation for his absence and demonstrate that his previous conduct was not indicative of an intention to abandon his defence," the decision reads.
Sukstorf had no trouble concluding that Yan was "ready, willing and able" to complete his purchase, and that Garrow and Benbow Residences had "repudiated" the contract.
Given this, Yan was within his rights to accept the company's repudiation of the contract and demand repayment of his $1-million deposit. The judge awarded him that amount.
She also awarded Yan special costs, citing Garrow and Benbow Properties' repeated failure to comply with "court orders and procedural obligations."
Sukstorf listed five document disclosure requests that the defendant "ignored," along with two orders issued by other judges with which the company "did not comply."
"In my view, the defendant’s repeated failure to comply with court orders, despite receiving clear instructions and multiple opportunities to do so, demonstrates a consistent disregard for the court’s authority that is deserving of rebuke," Sukstorf's decision reads.
"This behavior not only prejudiced Mr. Yan but also burdened the court system by necessitating repeated judicial intervention to enforce basic procedural requirements."
The amount Yan will be entitled to recover as special costs remains to be determined, according to the decision.
Notably, it appears that the company may have been dissolved. A company called Benbow Residences Inc. is among a list of hundreds of companies that were dissolved on July 3, 2023, according to a document published by B.C.'s Ministry of Citizens' Services.
"In the event of difficulty in recovering the $1 million, Mr. Yan may apply for such further relief as is necessary on notice to the defendant," Sukstorf's decision concludes.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
W5 Investigates Car security investigation: How W5 'stole' a car using a device we ordered online
In part two of a three-part series into how thieves are able to drive off with modern vehicles so easily, CTV W5 correspondent Jon Woodward uses a device flagged by police to easily clone a car key.
Satire slinger The Onion buys Alex Jones' Infowars at auction with help from Sandy Hook families
The satirical news publication The Onion won the bidding for Alex Jones' Infowars at a bankruptcy auction, backed by families of Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting victims whom Jones owes more than $1 billion in defamation judgments for calling the massacre a hoax, the families announced Thursday.
South African government says it won't help 4,000 illegal miners inside a closed mine
South Africa's government says it will not help an estimated 4,000 illegal miners inside a closed mine in the country's North West province who have been denied access to basic supplies as part of an official strategy against illegal mining.
2 B.C. Realtors fined $100K apiece for failing to disclose information to clients
Two B.C. real estate agents have been fined a combined total of more than $200,000 for professional misconduct they committed during the sale of a waterfront property on the Sunshine Coast in 2017.
Trump's defence secretary pick said women shouldn't be in combat roles. These female veterans fear what comes next
Female veterans fear the progress made for women in combat since then will be reversed after U.S. president-elect Donald Trump announced Pete Hegseth this week as his pick for secretary of defense – a Fox News host and Army veteran who has criticized efforts to allow women into combat roles.
'Only in Australia': Couple comes home to find koala in bed
Koalas are normally found in eucalyptus trees, but one couple came home in Australia on Wednesday and were shocked to find one in their bedroom.
B.C. midwives' college issues warnings about 4 unregistered women
The B.C. College of Nurses and Midwives has issued nearly identical warnings about four women, each of whom it says 'may be offering midwifery services' without being permitted to do so.
opinion Why the new U.S. administration won't have much time for us
In a column for CTVNews.ca, former Conservative Party political advisor and strategist Rudy Husny says that when Prime Minister Justin Trudeau goes to the G-20 summit next week, it will look more like his goodbye tour.
A look at how much mail Canada Post delivers, amid a strike notice
Amid a potential postal worker strike, here’s a look at how many letters and parcels the corporation delivers and how those numbers have changed in the internet age.