Class action lawsuit against Alesse to include those who took the birth control between 2017 and 2019
A national class action lawsuit against the pharmaceutical companies behind Alesse birth control will go forward in B.C. courts.
Two women, Taylor Janet MacKinnon and Alysa McIntosh, who say they got pregnant while taking Alesse, are leading the lawsuit, which was certified as a class action suit by a B.C. supreme court judge this week.
In the documents, both women share their stories of unexpected pregnancies, one having had a miscarriage and the other, who eventually gave birth to a child. They allege the companies were “high-handed, wanton and reckless” by producing and continuing to market a pill that they say was ineffective.
People from across Canada who were prescribed and took Alesse between January 1, 2017 and April 30, 2019 will be allowed to join the lawsuit, which is being stewarded by lawyers at Vancouver firm Rice Harbut Elliott, among others.
Before a class action lawsuit can be heard, a judge must first agree that the case should be heard as a class action suit.
“In this action, the plaintiffs allege that the defendants, Pfizer Canada Inc. and Wyeth Canada, negligently failed to take reasonable steps to ensure that Alesse was safe and effective for its intended use,” reads the June 7 ruling that said the case would proceed.
While the judge’s ruling means the class action lawsuit can proceed and be joined by other Alesse users, the allegations against the drug’s manufacturers have not been proven in court.
The women say there were “manufacturing defects in Alesse” between 2017 and 2019, which is backed up in part by a Health Canada advisory from December 2017, reads the ruling. The agency told consumers it had received complaints about broken and undersized pills in packages of Alesse 21 and Alesse 28, and issued a warning.
MacKinnon had been taking Alesse for several years to prevent pregnancy, and says she always took them as directed. At the beginning of December 2017, her pharmacist advised her of the recall and told her to check her pills for abnormalities. However, about 10 days later she discovered that she was already five weeks pregnant.
MacKinnon alleges she contacted Health Canada and Pfizer to alert them about what happened, but that neither provided her with much information.
She gave birth to a daughter about nine months later. She was 24 at the time of the birth, and says the early and unexpected pregnancy caused both financial and career instability.
“MacKinnon says she wished to have children someday but not at such a young age,” reads the judge’s ruling.
“She would have preferred that she and her partner were more established in their careers and financially stable before having children … she has not been able to find work as a certified dental assistant following the birth of her daughter.”
Meanwhile, McIntosh, who had been taking Alesse for about 11 months -- also as directed -- discovered she was pregnant at the end of October 2017, only to have a miscarriage near the beginning of December, when the fetus was about nine weeks old.
Lawyers had packages of Alesse tested by a lab, which found that some of the pills did not contain the amount of estrogen that was advertised on the packaging. The pills tested weren’t even the visibly broken or damaged pills that Health Canada had warned of.
“The plaintiffs say that an inference can be drawn that estrogen levels would be even lower in chipped or broken pills … (and the) testing demonstrates issues with estrogen levels that go beyond broken or chipped pills,” says the ruling.
According to the ruling, lawyers say that 138 people have contacted them to be part of the case, and Health Canada has a record of 38 people who had issues with the birth control. The overlap between the two lists is not yet known, and notice of the class action case has not yet been widely circulated.
Both women say the companies were negligent and are seeking financial damages. They also allege that by continuing to market Alesse despite the recalls and known issues, the companies deceived and misled consumers.
But the companies deny any wrongdoing. While the complainants will rely on three expert witnesses who say the lower levels of estrogen were likely to reduce the effectiveness of Alesse at preventing pregnancy, an expert witness for the companies disagrees. According to the ruling, that expert will argue that the reduced amount of estrogen in the pills was “within an acceptable range of deviation” that has “no impact on pregnancy rates.”
The companies also argue that the amount of estrogen in their pills was within a range accepted by Health Canada.
The judge notes that the women and others who apply to be part of the class action case may have difficulty proving that the pills had reduced effectiveness, but said they presented enough information to be certified and allowed to proceed with their case.
Provincial health-care services from across the country are also joining the class action case, and will be seeking to recover the health-care costs associated with what they say was negligence from Pfizer and Wyeth.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Pedestrian, baby injured after stroller struck and dragged by vehicle in Squamish, B.C.
Police say a baby and a pedestrian suffered non-life-threatening injuries after a vehicle struck a baby stroller and dragged it for two blocks before stopping in Squamish, B.C.
Senate expenses climbed to $7.2 million in 2023, up nearly 30%
Senators in Canada claimed $7.2 million in expenses in 2023, a nearly 30 per cent increase over the previous year.
Demonstrators kicked out of Ontario legislature for disruption after failed keffiyeh vote
A group of demonstrators were kicked out of the legislature after a second NDP motion calling for unanimous consent to reverse a ban on the keffiyeh failed to pass.
Tom Mulcair: Park littered with trash after 'pilot project' is perfect symbol of Trudeau governance
Former NDP leader Tom Mulcair says that what's happening now in a trash-littered federal park in Quebec is a perfect metaphor for how the Trudeau government runs things.
RCMP uncovers alleged plot by 2 Montreal men to illegally sell drones, equipment to Libya
The RCMP says it has uncovered a plot by two men in Montreal to sell Chinese drones and military equipment to Libya illegally.
Government agrees to US$138.7M settlement over FBI's botching of Larry Nassar assault allegations
The U.S. Justice Department announced a US$138.7 million settlement Tuesday with more than 100 people who accused the FBI of grossly mishandling allegations of sexual assault against Larry Nassar in 2015 and 2016, a critical time gap that allowed the sports doctor to continue to prey on victims before his arrest.
Man wanted in connection with deadly shooting in Toronto tops list of most wanted fugitives in Canada
A 35-year-old man wanted in connection with the murder of Toronto resident 29-year-old Sharmar Powell-Flowers nine months ago has topped the list of the BOLO program’s 25 most wanted fugitives across Canada, police announced Tuesday.
Doctors ask Liberal government to reconsider capital gains tax change
The Canadian Medical Association is asking the federal government to reconsider its proposed changes to capital gains taxation, arguing it will affect doctors' retirement savings.
Pro-Palestinian protests roiling U.S. colleges escalate with arrests, new encampments and closures
The student protests of Israel's war with Hamas that have been creating friction at U.S. universities escalated Tuesday as new encampments sprouted and some colleges encouraged students to stay home and learn online, after dozens of arrests across the country.