B.C. woman can sue bank for allowing her to transfer $69K to fraudsters, appeal court rules
B.C. woman can sue bank for allowing her to transfer $69K to fraudsters, appeal court rules
B.C.'s highest court has given new life to a fraud victim's case against her bank, which she alleges had a duty to warn her about scams that had been reported in the community before allowing her to transfer $69,000 overseas.
A B.C. Supreme Court judge had previously granted the bank's application to dismiss the case on the grounds that there was no reasonable prospect that the fraud victim – Li Zheng – would succeed in a trial.
The B.C. Court of Appeal disagreed, ordering the bank's application for summary judgment to be dismissed, and allowing the original case to proceed.
THE FRAUD
Writing for the appeal court's three-judge panel, Justice Susan Griffin summarized the facts alleged in Zheng's initial lawsuit.
"Ms. Zheng alleges that she received a phone call on May 15, 2018, from a person purporting to be with the Chinese consulate," the decision reads.
"The person had the number from her driver’s license, which was only one month old. The person told her that the international police were looking for her and that she was accused of being involved in an international money laundering case."
The fraudsters told Zheng that she would have to fly back to China to stay in jail during the investigation or transfer funds to Hong Kong, which would be returned to her after the investigation.
One week later, on May 22, Zheng went to a branch of the Bank of China (Canada) in Richmond and asked a teller to help her send $69,000 from her account to an account in someone else's name in one of the bank's branches in Hong Kong.
As part of the transfer process, Zheng signed an "application for remittance" that included an "exclusion-of-liability clause" releasing the bank from legal responsibility for problems arising from the transfer.
Zheng alleged that neither the teller nor another bank employee she spoke to asked her any questions about the transfer, though the bank's response to her claim indicated that internal control and compliance officer Bin Zhang asked about the relationship between Zheng and her intended recipient.
"(Zhang) deposed that he asked her this because it was an international transaction greater than $10,000, but Ms. Zheng did not answer his question," Griffin wrote in her decision.
"He deposed that he 'did not notice anything out of the ordinary.'"
Zheng learned in June 2018 that she had been the victim of fraud, and that scams of this type had been reported on in local media before she made her transaction, according to the decision.
She filed her lawsuit in August 2020, alleging that "the bank knew of this prevailing fraud at the time of the transaction" and had a duty to warn her about it.
THE DISMISSAL
The bank's application to dismiss the case was first heard by a master of the B.C. Supreme Court, who granted it.
When Zheng appealed, a chambers judge reviewed the master's decision and did not find grounds for overturning it, though he disagreed with the master's conclusion that a claim based on the bank having a duty to inform Zheng of the fraud was bound to fail.
It was possible, the chambers judge wrote, that the bank would have a duty to "at least make an inquiry with Ms. Zheng about the potential for fraud," if Zheng's allegation that the fraud was "prevailing" in major Canadian cities at the time was found to be accurate.
"I would suggest that much turns on the extent of what the bank knew, or ought to have known, about this particular scheme and how specific that information was," the chambers judge wrote, as quoted in Griffin's appeal decision.
Despite this, the chambers judge dismissed Zheng's initial appeal, upholding the outcome of the master's initial decision, because he found the exclusion clause would apply and "there was no reasonable prospect that Ms. Zheng could establish her loss was solely caused by the bank’s negligence or wilful misconduct," Griffin summarized.
THE APPEAL
This line of reasoning is where the appeal judges disagreed with the chambers judge. While they accepted that the exclusion clause would defeat Zheng's claim if it applied, they disagreed with the chambers judge's finding that it must apply.
"The judge failed to consider that … Ms. Zheng has an available argument at trial that the bank’s error arose before the processing of the transfer instructions and therefore outside of the context and application of the exclusion clause," Griffin wrote.
If the bank had a duty to warn Zheng about the possibility of fraud, that duty could have come into play as soon as she inquired about making such a large transfer, before the bank asked her to sign the exclusion clause, the appeal judges concluded.
"I see the application and interpretation of the exclusion clause in this case as depending on the facts of the bank’s knowledge of the prevailing fraud and its duty to warn Ms. Zheng before it asked her to provide a signed application for remittance," Griffin wrote. "Since there is a genuine issue for trial about those facts, the judge ought not to have interpreted the exclusion clause as barring the claim."
Accordingly, the appeal judges allowed Zheng's appeal, set aside the chambers judge's order, and substituted an order that the bank's application to dismiss the case be, itself, dismissed.
U.S. President Joe Biden arrived Thursday evening in Ottawa for a whirlwind 27-hour visit expected to focus on both the friendly and thorny aspects of the Canada-U.S. relationship, including protectionism and migration on both sides of the border.
Canada and the United States are negotiating a deal that could see asylum seekers turned back at irregular border crossings across the border, including Roxham Road in Quebec.
As the federal government looks to renegotiate the Safe Third Country Agreement with the U.S., an eastern Ontario mayor says his city needs more help from Ottawa to deal with the influx of asylum seekers arriving through irregular crossings like Roxham Road.
Amid renewed questions over the pervasiveness of alleged interference by China in Canadian elections and affairs broadly, opposition MPs voted Thursday afternoon to affirm a parliamentary committee's call for the federal government to strike a public inquiry.
A majority of Canadians have seen a mistake on their grocery receipts in the last year, according to a new survey conducted by Agri-Food Analytics Lab at Dalhousie University.
An asteroid discovered just last week will pass closer to the Earth than the orbit of the moon this weekend, an occurrence so rare it happens only once in a decade, according to NASA.
The number of Canadians receiving employment insurance benefits are at record lows and down 44 per cent from last year, new figures from Statistics Canada show.
Two Kanien'keha:ka (Mohawk) sisters from Montreal are on a mission that is close to their hearts: to save their ancestors' first language by developing video games young and old can play.
A Victoria man’s life of crime has turned into one of survival, hope and advocacy amid ongoing conversations in the community about how best to tackle public safety matters.
The Alberta Energy Regulator has cited an energy company for causing a series of earthquakes, including the largest recorded tremblor in the province's history.
The Alberta Energy Regulator has cited an energy company for causing a series of earthquakes, including the largest recorded tremblor in the province's history.
An Ontario man said he was shocked when his truck was stolen not once but twice, and the second time it was taken he was surprised to discover he was no longer covered for theft.
For the first time, the owner of a building in Old Montreal has responded to questions about the fire — through his lawyer — addressing allegations that the building was unsafe.
The political class at the National Assembly has condemned the 'violent' and 'hateful' remarks that columnist Gilles Proulx allegedly made about Quebec solidaire MNAs during Richard Martineau's show on Qub radio in recent weeks.
Manitoba First Nation police have arrested a man connected with a shooting on March 19 on Long Plain First Nation that resulted in the community going on lockdown.
Manitoba’s labour force is growing at a rate to supply enough workers for available positions into 2026, according to the province’s labour market outlook.
An alleged victim of a former staff member of Legacy Christian Academy can now be identified after she successfully petitioned in court to have a publication ban lifted.
In the weeks leading up to Wednesday’s provincial budget, school divisions in Saskatchewan were expecting funding levels to increase, with the province repeatedly touting its $1 billion surplus.
A recent report from the province’s privacy commissioner says the Métis Addictions Council of Saskatchewan Inc. (MACSI) failed to take appropriate steps after patient treatment files were discovered in a recycling bin.
The Tim Houston PC government remains firm in their promise they'll fix the health-care system by spending more taxpayer money on health than any previous government before.
Potato farmers on Prince Edward Island are taking the federal government to court due to the decision to restrict the movement of P.E.I. seed potatoes.
The new provincial budget features items specific to southwestern Ontario, including a new English public elementary school in London, Ont. that will serve 556 students and include 88 licensed childcare spaces.
A young Strathroy, Ont. man believes there's a promising way forward in the effort to fight his disease. But, he's being told, right now, that path isn't open to him. Friends and family are stepping up to try and make a case for Kyle McPhee to receive immunotherapy treatments.
The co-owners of a new liquidation store in North Bay, Samuel Quesnel and Chloé Boivenue, say they want to bring a treasure hunt shopping experience to the city.
The ‘Catch the Ace’ jackpot is still up for grabs in Hagersville. There was no winner Thursday night so the total prize money is now an estimated $1,526,067.
The resurrection of Zellers is officially underway with the Cambridge location opening its doors to eager shoppers who lined up ahead of the store's official reopening.
