B.C. man on the hook for strata's $15K in legal fees, tribunal finds
The "volume and severity" of complaints against a B.C. condo owner for violating building bylaws were sufficient to justify hiring a lawyer to handle them, a tribunal has ruled, dismissing the man's bid to be let off the hook for $15,000 in legal fees.
Michael Throssell was disputing the legal bill he was handed by his strata council before he sold his unit and moved out – even though paying the legal fees was part of a settlement he reached with the strata council.
Because Throssell had not actually signed that agreement, the tribunal found it was not binding and proceeded to decide the matter of whether the fees were reasonable and necessary in the circumstances.
The decision, published last week, summarized the alleged bylaw breaches for which Throssell was fined.
"These alleged breaches included several instances of noise and nuisance, unauthorized parking, unauthorized rentals, unauthorized fob usage, an unkempt patio, smoking, and common property damage, " tribunal member Alison Wake wrote.
"The strata did not fine Mr. Throssell for all of the alleged breaches, but did fine him a total of $1,400 for noise, nuisance, smoking, and property damage."
According to the decision, the strata's bylaws spell out that an owner is liable for legal fees in cases like these. However, Wake noted that there is an established exception to this if alleged bylaw breaches are "unproven and not admitted."
Throssell argued, in part, that this applied in his case – describing the fines associated with bylaw breaches as "erroneous." However, the decisions said he did not meet his burden to establish that the bylaw contraventions did not occur and that the fines were improperly imposed.
Throssell also argued it was unreasonable and unnecessary for the strata to hire a lawyer to handle the matter and that the legal fees were "exorbitant."
The strata, for its part, argued it had "no choice" but to engage a lawyer. In support of this claim, evidence was submitted showing warnings that went unheeded and fines that went unpaid.
Further, the strata told the tribunal that the situation escalated to the point where police and a SWAT team were called to Throssell's unit – something he did not dispute.
"Overall, given the volume and severity of bylaw complaints, I find it was reasonable for the strata to engage its lawyer to correspond with Mr. Throssell about the alleged bylaw breaches," Wake writes.
When it came to the amount of the fees, the tribunal found that the strata kept Throssell informed about the rising bill by providing him with regular statements of account.
"I find Mr. Throssell has not established that the strata improperly charged him for its legal fees," the decision concluded.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Canadian comedian, talk show host Mike Bullard dead at 67
Canadian stand-up comedian and former talk show host Mike Bullard has died.
Thousands of miles from home, Trudeau learns of dissension in his caucus
The free trade agreement with ASEAN is expected to be signed at the end of 2025. If Trudeau is pressured to step down, or if his government falls and loses the next election, Trudeau will not, as prime minister, be there to see the fruits of his labour.
Here's the dirt on the germiest items in your day-to-day life
Your home – considered to be one of the safest havens from all the external stresses – is filthy.
Should men and women eat different breakfasts? Study suggests they should
The study, which uses a mathematical model, indicates that men and women may benefit from different breakfast choices to optimize metabolism and potentially aid weight management.
Trump suggests a protester may get 'the hell knocked out of her' by her parents
Former U.S. president Donald Trump called for a protester at one of his rallies to 'go back home to Mommy' to 'get the hell knocked out of her,' his latest instance of using violent language when confronted by demonstrators.
Israel's military says 4 soldiers were killed in a Hezbollah drone attack
A Hezbollah drone attack on an army base in central Israel killed four soldiers and severely wounded seven others Sunday, the military said, in the deadliest strike by the militant group since Israel launched its ground invasion of Lebanon nearly two weeks ago.
Ukrainian journalist Victoria Roshchyna dies in Russian detention, Kyiv says
Ukrainian journalist Victoria Roshchyna, who went missing in an occupied part of her country, died in Russian detention last month, Ukrainian authorities said earlier this week.
Man charged after dead body found inside east Toronto apartment
Police have arrested and charged a 52-year-old man who wanted after failing to notify authorities about a dead person inside an apartment in Toronto’s Riverside neighbourhood.
Emaciated orca calf spotted off Vancouver Island, researchers say
Just a couple of weeks after a new southern resident killer whale calf was first seen, its health appears to have taken a bad turn.