B.C. man allowed to keep Great Dane in condo where pets prohibited: tribunal
A B.C. man has won his fight to keep a Great Dane in his condo – despite the building’s ban on pets.
The province’s civil resolution tribunal ruled on the dispute Tuesday, finding the dog functions as an emotional support animal and that removing it would be tantamount to discrimination and would violate of the Human Rights Code.
The decision notes that the building bylaws explicitly ban owners or occupants from having “any dog, cat or other animal” and give the strata, which oversees bylaw enforcement, the power to demand that pets be removed and to impose fines on people who break the rules.
The strata brought a claim asking for an order that Lawrence Lee’s dog be removed and that he pay $17,200 in bylaw fines.
The bylaw exemption
But the strata also admitted it granted Lee an exemption from the no-pet policy in June of 2021 based on a doctor’s note indicating that Lee suffered from anxiety and depression. The note, according to the decision, also said that Lee had a history of “’seeking euthanasia’ due to loneliness” and that it explicitly said Lee was at an “increased risk of death” if he did not have a companion animal.
The strata argued that the exemption granted was for a small dog, specifically a Yorkshire terrier. In March of 2022, Lee and Cindy Lajoie Laframboise, who also lives in the condo, brought home the Great Dane. They told the tribunal they did not seek permission before getting a second dog and that the strata denied their request for an additional dog when it was made two months later.
The tribunal found the strata was entitled to deny a second dog, with the decision saying the doctor’s notes in evidence were “too vague to be interpreted to mean Mr. Lee required two dogs.”
But the terrier died in July of 2022, leaving only one, large dog in the unit.
“Just because Mr. Lee did not get pre-approval for the Great Dane does not mean the strata can ban the dog after his circumstances changed,” tribunal member J. Garth Cambrey wrote.
Undue hardship?
The strata did not dispute that Lee had a disability that “requires him to have a dog” nor did it dispute the legal duty to accommodate Lee by allowing a dog.
Instead, it made several arguments that this dog – in particular – should be removed.
First, the strata submitted that the exemption to the bylaw allowed Lee to have the Yorkshire terrier or a “similar- sized” replacement. That argument was rejected with the tribunal finding the exemption did not restrict the size or breed of dog allowed.
Second, the strata argued the dog was aggressive. Evidence in support of this included a petition signed by 80 residents of the building and video that showed the Great Dane “jumping up on one individual and biting another individual” in September of 2023. The strata called the BC SPCA as a result of these incidents.
“An animal control officer attended (the unit) and spoke to one of the respondents about the dog’s unacceptable behaviour,” the decision says.
“The officer confirmed that based on their knowledge, it was not a situation where the animal would be removed.”
The tribunal also noted that the dog’s behaviour evidently improved after the SC SPCA officer attended and that the owners said the dog had been working with a trainer.
Because of this, the tribunal found there was not enough evidence to show that the dog was aggressive and that allowing the residents to keep it would be an “undue hardship” for the strata, which would provide legal justification for not allowing the dog.
“I dismiss the strata’s request that the dog be removed, and I grant the respondents’ requested order that the Great Dane be permitted to remain in (the unit). Since my reasons are based on Mr. Lee’s disability, I find the Great Dane may remain in (the unit) for as long as Mr. Lee resides there,” Cambrey wrote.
While the majority of bylaw fines were removed, the tribunal did find that having two dogs was a breach and upheld $800 in fines for the period when that was the case.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING India withdraws Canada envoy named in probe, expels diplomats
India ordered the expulsion of six Canadian diplomats on Monday and withdrew its own envoy from Canada, in response to what it said was Ottawa's decision to name him and others as 'persons of interest' in an investigation.
Ontario police say 'escalating incidents' between high schools connected to deadly crash
'Escalating incidents' between two Hamilton high schools are believed to be connected to a car crash last week that left a 15-year-old boy dead, police say.
Undercooked bear meat linked to outbreak of rare parasitic disease in U.S.
An outbreak of a rare parasitic disease has been linked to undercooked bear meat eaten by dozens of people at a gathering in North Carolina, a new U.S. CDC report has revealed.
Canadian drink company tastes controversy after Simu Liu raises cultural appropriation questions
Controversy bubbled for a Canadian drink company after its founders drew the ire of a Marvel superhero on an episode of a 'Shark Tank'-style reality series.
'We apologize to anyone we've offended': Bath and Body Works pulls candles over backlash
A major American retailer has stopped selling its new winter-themed candle over backlash from shoppers who said its design resembled Ku Klux Klan hoods.
Striking images show rare floods in the largest hot desert on Earth
Striking images from the Sahara Desert show large lakes etched into rolling sand dunes after one of the most arid, barren places in the world was hit with its first floods in decades.
Father of 10-year-old girl found dead in the U.K. called police from Pakistan to say he killed her
The father of a 10-year-old girl found dead in her home in England fled to Pakistan and called U.K. police from there to say he had killed her, a jury heard Monday.
NASA spacecraft rockets toward Jupiter's moon Europa in search of the right conditions for life
A NASA spacecraft rocketed away Monday on a quest to explore Jupiter’s tantalizing moon Europa and reveal whether its vast hidden ocean might hold the keys to life.
Canadian comedian, talk show host Mike Bullard dead at 67
Canadian stand-up comedian and former talk show host Mike Bullard has died.