B.C. court upholds public health-care principles, striking down appeal
A Vancouver surgeon and businessman has lost his appeal of a landmark court case that threatened the foundations of the Canadian health-care system.
The B.C. Court of Appeal has dismissed the appeal brought by Dr. Brian Day of the Cambie Surgical Centre, finding that a 2020 judgment from a lower court judge was appropriate in their 142-page ruling. Appeals only address perceived errors in law, not the fundamental facts established by the initial judgment.
Day had argued that British Columbians had the right to pay for private medical treatment, primarily scheduled day surgeries, because waits in the public system were so long, they violated patients’ constitutional rights to life, liberty and the security of the person under Section 7 of the Charter.
The Court of Appeal described Day’s argument as patients suffering “when the public system is broken and has failed to deliver on its promise of timely quality care, unjustly prevents individuals from using their own resources to meet their health-care needs,” and that “permitting parallel private care would act as a safety valve, relieving the pressure on the public system without harming it.”
While they disagreed with lawyers for the attorney general, representing the province, who had argued “the case was really about the financial interests and preferred business model of some physicians and private clinics,” the court of appeal did agree that equitable health care for all was of paramount importance.
“We’re disappointed,” Day told CTV News after the decision.
"This ruling means more Canadians are going to die before we fix the system.”
Day first launched the legal action back in 2009, before it finally made it to the B.C. Supreme Court in 2016.
GOVERNMENT AND ADVOCATES PLEASED
Asked for reaction to the latest development, B.C. Health Minister Adrian Dix said the government is “very pleased of the decision of the court to support Canada's public health-care system.”
The BC Health Coalition, which has denounced the creep of privatized medicine into the public system, also applauded the decision.
"We can go to a hospital or a doctors office and we don’t walk away with a bill for $10,000. That would be in essence what we would start to see if the legislative framework is unravelled," said policy analyst, Andrew Longhurst.
"(Two-tiered medicine) would drain resources – limited health-care professionals, doctors, surgeons, nurses – out of the public system."
A SLIGHT DISAGREEMENT
While she agreed with her two colleagues that health care should be available to all based on their needs, rather than financial wherewithal, one of the judges essentially argued it’s unfair for patients to suffer because governments have decided to fund and operate the health-care system at current service levels.
“It is more than incommensurate to ask patients to risk irremediable harm and increased risk of death in order to preserve a public health-care system that is intentionally under-designed in order to achieve fiscal sustainability,” wrote justice Lauri Ann Fenlon, who pointed out the truly wealthy already travel to the United States or other countries and pay for swift access to medical services.
She acknowledged there is a “legal dissonance” in finding that a law is constitutional while being contradictory to the principles of fundamental justice.
“The record and findings of the judge amply support his conclusion that a duplicative system would result in longer wait times and, therefore, even poorer care for those who would have no option but the public system,” wrote Fenlon.
“We do not find that the judge overstated the societal benefits of the suppression of private care or the negative effects of striking the provisions on the sustainability and effectiveness of the public system.”
Day said he’s frustrated that despite recognizing that, the court ultimately upheld a system that has thousands waiting for medically necessary procedures.
"They deferred to government, essentially saying: ‘Yes, patients are suffering and dying but governments have the right to allow that,’" he said.
Day said he will now seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.
Correction
This story has been updated to correct the court's position on the argument from lawyers for the attorney general that the case was "really about the financial interests and preferred business model of some physicians and private clinics."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
'They needed people inside Air Canada:' Police announce arrests in Pearson gold heist
Police say one former and one current employee of Air Canada are among the nine suspects that are facing charges in connection with the gold heist at Pearson International Airport last year.
House admonishes ArriveCan contractor in rare parliamentary show of power
MPs enacted an extraordinary, rarely used parliamentary power on Wednesday, summonsing an ArriveCan contractor to appear before the House of Commons where he was admonished publicly and forced to provide answers to the questions MPs said he'd previously evaded.
Leafs star Auston Matthews finishes season with 69 goals
Auston Matthews won't be joining the NHL's 70-goal club this season.
Trump lawyers say Stormy Daniels refused subpoena outside a Brooklyn bar, papers left 'at her feet'
Donald Trump's legal team says it tried serving Stormy Daniels a subpoena as she arrived for an event at a bar in Brooklyn last month, but the porn actor, who is expected to be a witness at the former president's criminal trial, refused to take it and walked away.
Why drivers in Eastern Canada could see big gas price spikes, and other Canadians won't
Drivers in Eastern Canada face a big increase in gas prices because of various factors, especially the higher cost of the summer blend, industry analysts say.
Doug Ford calls on Ontario Speaker to reverse Queen's Park keffiyeh ban
Ontario Premier Doug Ford is calling on Speaker Ted Arnott to reverse a ban on keffiyehs at Queen's Park, describing the move as “needlessly” divisive.
'A living nightmare': Winnipeg woman sentenced following campaign of harassment against man after online date
A Winnipeg woman was sentenced to house arrest after a single date with a man she met online culminated in her harassing him for years, and spurred false allegations which resulted in the innocent man being arrested three times.
Woman who pressured boyfriend to kill his ex in 2000s granted absences from prison
A woman who pressured her boyfriend into killing his teenage ex more than a decade ago will be allowed to leave prison for weeks at a time.
Customers disappointed after email listing $60K Tim Hortons prize sent in error
Several Tim Horton’s customers are feeling great disappointment after being told by the company that an email stating they won a boat worth nearly $60,000 was sent in error.