Anti-vax blog post not admissible, B.C. court rules in vaccination dispute
A B.C. father who printed off a blog post and submitted it to court in a bid to prevent his children's mother from vaccinating them against COVID-19 has lost the dispute, in part because the judge found his evidence inadmissible.
The family law case represents yet another instance in which an anti-vaccine parent failed to convince a Canadian judge that immunization posed a significant risk to their child, and ultimately lost decision-making authority on the matter.
The couple at the centre of the latest case, identified in court documents as C.H. and A.T., have two children, aged seven and nine.
Provincial court judge Wilson Lee's decision, which was posted online this week, noted that "both parties clearly love their children, and wish only the best for them."
"They disagree on this one issue, which has been the subject of debate throughout our society since the advent of the pandemic and the development of vaccines," Lee wrote.
But in court proceedings, disagreements are settled using compelling and reliable evidence – and the judge found the mother, Ms. T., was the only one who presented any at their hearing.
She brought letters from their children's doctors recommending that each of them receive the COVID-19 vaccine, as well as information from BC Children's Hospital, the Government of Canada, the Ministry of Health, and ImmunizeBC, all supporting the safety of vaccination.
The father, Mr. H., presented two printouts, including a Wordpress blog without a named author that discusses documents related to the development of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine. Lee found the printout was not admissible as evidence.
"At best, the blog post is an opinion that does not satisfy any of the requirements for an expert report," he wrote. "Even if the blog post were admissible as evidence, it only raises unsupported suspicions."
The other printout, which lacked as much as a source, described the typical timeline for vaccine development. The judge acknowledged the COVID-19 vaccine was developed more quickly.
But going on established case law regarding the COVID-19 vaccine, Lee noted several recurring principles, including that "COVID-19 vaccination is deemed to be in the best interests of a child" and that a "wait and see approach" of the kind advocated by Mr. H. "is not in the best interests of a child, especially when weighed against the risks of COVID-19 itself."
"The evidence submitted by Mr. H. does not rebut these presumptions," Lee wrote.
"I order that A.T. will have the parenting responsibility and authorization to obtain for the children the COVID-19 vaccination, including two doses, and a booster if and when recommended, without the consent of C.H."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Lack of detention space could force CBSA to release detainees, internal memo warns
The Canada Border Services Agency is scrambling to find space to hold high-risk detainees that are set to be transferred from provincial jails in June.
BREAKING American millionaire Jonathan Lehrer denied bail after being charged with killing Canadian couple
American millionaire Jonathan Lehrer, one of two men charged in the killings of a Canadian couple in Dominica, has been denied bail.
BREAKING Allman Brothers Band co-founder and legendary guitarist Dickey Betts dies at 80
Guitar legend Dickey Betts, who co-founded the Allman Brothers Band and wrote their biggest hit, 'Ramblin' Man,' has died. He was 80.
Trend Line Anger, pessimism towards federal government reach six-year high: Nanos survey
Most Canadians in March reported feeling angry or pessimistic towards the federal government than at any point in the last six years, according to a survey by Nanos Research.
Police make arrests in grandparent scam that defrauded victims out of $739K
Ontario Provincial Police say they have 'disrupted' an organized crime group that allegedly used an emergency grandparent scam to defraud seniors across Canada out of hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Motion to allow keffiyehs at Ontario legislature fails
A motion to reverse a ban on the keffiyeh within Queen’s Park failed to receive unanimous consent Thursday just moments after Ontario Premier Doug Ford reiterated his view that prohibiting the garment in the House is divisive.
What does it mean to be 'house poor' and how can you avoid it?
The journey to home ownership can be exciting, but personal finance columnist Christopher Liew warns about the trappings of becoming 'house poor' -- where an overwhelming portion of your income is devoured by housing costs. Liew offers some practical strategies to maintain better financial health while owning a home.
Calgary man charged with manslaughter in death of toddler
Calgary police say Winston Campbell, 45, has been charged in the death of a two-year-old girl in 2022.
B.C. child killer's lawyer walks out of review hearing
The lawyer representing child-killer Allan Schoenborn walked out of his client's annual review hearing Wednesday – abruptly ending proceedings marked by tense exchanges and several outbursts.